newbie here! :D

before hand, i'd like to say that these retouched images were made years ago when i was sort of a newbie in the 'retouching' business as well (not that i'm anywhere near professional anyway).
i'd love to hear some critique from you guys :D

http://fc02.deviantart.com/fs21/f/2007/304/9/9/9959fa3c2e000f0c.jpg
made about four years ago i think?

http://fc05.deviantart.com/fs20/f/2007/306/6/1/61e4e9527b6ed658.jpg
this one from last year

http://untrue.deviantart.com/art/retouching-06-68685035
and this one is more of a manipulation/edition than retouching.


(:

Bem vindo! =D

Vou falar em inglês pro pessoal não reclamar... ok?

First and second images - Skin looks blured, without any details at wall. Skin without pores looks fake... so, you need to fix that. Never blur.

Third one - I really like that one. Looks natural. I like what you did in her eyes (some maybe thought that's too much but.. that's my opinion). You could maybe, play a little more with shadows in her body, you know?

I tried this one myself. I really like the britney one. its crazy how celebs dont looks anything like what they do in the magz.

The first retouched (Madonna) looks artificial to me, maybe you can change the color a bit but the other 2 looks good.

The retouch looks good to me.
I suggest you change the skin tone it really looks not natural to the naked eye.