Feb 06 Contest Discussion

[byRo]

Add your comments, questions or general discussion about the Feb 06 Contest entries as well as the contest itself here.

This is also a great place to share your techniques or ask others about theirs.

Rô

[NancyJ]

You're an evil man byRo

Just one question you say

Portrait Retouch - make this into a great photo, but without altering the subjects.

Does that mean we have to keep both subjects in the picture? Because that seems in conflict with

This is a Restoration and Portrait Retouch: The final imge should look like it was shot yesterday, by a professional photographer, straight out of the camera

The poor lady is missing half her head, now I'm sure we've all done a bit of transplant surgery on a missing body part - but half a head it going to be very noticeable Particularly to the lady in the photo

[byRo]

Evil, me?
Nah, if I was evil I'd say "That's your problem. Deal with it!"

..well come to think of it I am going to say that - but in a rather more educated way (of course).

Yes, you are stuck with (less than) half of the mother's face. You can't take it away completely, nor can you complete it. Should be interesting to see how folks get around this.

OK, so I am evil after all.

Rô

[twinkissed]

Oy!

That's about all I have to say about this one. lol

[TwinbNJ]

This is a challenge to say the least!

[NancyJ]

so... we have to make it look like a professional photo, with the mothers head chopped off - thats more than a challenge.

Its gonna take more than a crate of beer to think outside the box on this one...

[TwinbNJ]

Nancy -


Or a case of wine!!!

[NancyJ]

I think the only solution is enough absinthe to see Kylie as the absinthe fairy (Moulin Rouge reference )

[TwinbNJ]

LOL - I hear ya!

[Peter S]

Ro

You say we are stuck with half a woman, ?
But in the rules you say

3. Your final image size must be exactly 800 by 600 px, in either orientation.

I would take this to mean we could crop to 800 high by 600 wide. If we do we must loose some of the picture, can't that be the Mother??

Peter


I agree with the others you are showing your nasty side with this one

[byRo]

Originally Posted by Peter (and all)

I agree with the others you are showing your nasty side with this one

Don't worry, T will be back soon. It's just to make you miss her even more.

If we do we must loose some of the picture, can't that be the Mother??

Well, you could - but then the guys that didn't just might discount that come voting time.

Beer? Wine?? Absinthe??? Ladies please! No need for this.
Nothing that a couple of "caipirinhas " wouldn't fix.

Thanks to the reigning champ Robin for kicking off.

Rô

[TwinbNJ]

Thanks Ro! the caipirinhas did it! Just the inspiration I needed.

Fixing colors is not something I am good at, that made this more difficult than just keeping both subjects in the picture!

[NancyJ]

Originally Posted by byRo

Beer? Wine?? Absinthe??? Ladies please! No need for this.
Nothing that a couple of "caipirinhas " wouldn't fix.

Bit chilli for that round here, 12.4 degrees c right now.
My god you people are quick, I've barely even investigated it. I think that blue channel is going to give me nightmares

[Doug Colwell]

Maybe the instructions should be amended to read 'by a drunk professional photographer' ? Anyone else having problems opening Robin's pic in photoshop? I get a 'could not open the document because of a disk error' message. It opens fine in the windows image viewer so it's not a big deal, but would like to know if the bug is in the file or in my photoshop app.

[NancyJ]

Originally Posted by Doug Colwell

Maybe the instructions should be amended to read 'by a drunk professional photographer' ?.

I think mine will probably end up as 'by a drunk professional photographer with his cell phone camera

[chrishoggy]

Opens OK for me in CS2 Doug

[RL Design]

Originally Posted by Doug Colwell

Anyone else having problems opening Robin's pic in photoshop? I get a 'could not open the document because of a disk error' message. It opens fine in the windows image viewer so it's not a big deal, but would like to know if the bug is in the file or in my photoshop app.

Hi Doug - the file is saved a a JPEG from Photoshop. I am working on a Mac, so no worries about viruses. If needed I can resave and reattach.

[Doug Colwell]

Hi Robin, I tried opening your Jan pic too and got the same error, so I'm thinking my PS5.5 can't understand the Mac version. So far yours is the only one I can't open. No need to re-save or anything thanks - if I come across more I'll just have more excuses to upgrade to CS.

[SWEngineer]

After literally working all night on this giving the mother a nose and eyes, I read the comments thread and learn this isn't allowed. Thus the title. Drunk pro photographer or not, you're pushing me towards drunk amature restorer/retoucher.

Not willing to waste this effort, and with due apologies to the real mother (& father, & child), I'm posting the result of my hard, non-elegible work here.

I'll come up with a legit entry after I work off my sleep deficit.
In the mean time you all (especially byRo ) better be replying with some sympathy (or at least some constructive criticism ).

BTW, you get the improper size version. I already spent extra time fixing this too. Maybe I have a problem reading directions?

[videosean]

What pro would use a 126 camera? Especially yesterday
Great challenge!

[Doug Colwell]

Looks great SW Engineer. Maybe you'll spark a side contest in the discussion forum????

[TwinbNJ]

SWEngineer - OUCH - I feel your pain!

Great job on the reconstruction of mom. When I first opened the challenge I thought "OK do we have to create mom? How can you Keep both subjects in the picture from a "proffesional" that CUT mom's head off!!!! " LOL

Well you can always crop out all that work you did (BIG OUCH) and go from there. Best of luck.

[byRo]

Originally Posted by videosean

What pro would use a 126 camera? Especially yesterday

110 actually.

You guys are doing great! The way this started I thought nobody was even going to enter.

Aha, so you like 'em tough then..

..OK, wait till you see next month

Oops, forgot. T's back next month.
Don't know if that's going to make it any easier though.

SWEngineer, nice try. I've got another photo taken the same day, I'll post it later so you can see how close you came.

Rô

[HannibalVector]

A question for byRo:
May I use the original picture and my version for my portfolio?

[byRo]

Hi there, Hannibal. welcome to RetouchPRO

OK, no problem. The photographer and models have given their consent.

Rô

[byRo]

I think times about up!

But as the site seemed to be a bit on the blink today, and seeing as summer-time just finished here (and I'm a bit lost where GMT is now); the contest will end in (about) three hours from now.

LAST CHANCE!

Rô

[NancyJ]

..Time check - was working late tonight, looks like I'm gonna miss this one.

[twinkissed]

Just can't help but have that Jeopardy game show tune in my head...

Time being almost up and all

[byRo]

The contest entries are now closed.

A very big Thank You to all that decided to take up this difficult challenge.

The voting thread is now open.

You may observe that there have been some slight amendments to the voting rules. Nothing special - just trying to avoid some awkward situations that could come up one day.

See you there!

Rô

[HannibalVector]

Originally Posted by byRo

Hi there, Hannibal. welcome to RetouchPRO

Thanks, I like it here!

Originally Posted by byRo

OK, no problem. The photographer and models have given their consent.

Thanks,
But first I have to build my website, I put a link in my profile when I am ready!