June 06 Votes

[T Paul]

Voting will run from 24 June to 30 June 2006. Deadline for votes is 6pm EDT 30 June 2006.

Only those that entered the contest may vote. All other votes will be deleted. If you did not enter, but would like to comment on an entry, please post your comments to the June 06 Discussion Thread.

Vote for the 5 best entries in order.

Note you cannot vote for your own image. If you do, your votes will be deleted.

Example Vote:
Pick the top five contest entries and list in order...

1. Entry X (First Place)
2. Entry A (Second Place and so on)
3. Entry Q
4. Entry S
5. Entry P

This thread will remain closed until it's time to vote.

And as always, when you vote try to include some things you especially liked about your choices…what made them stand out, what impressed you, etc. This is a learning experience!

[T Paul]

Makeovermagic has been kind enough to once again create a photo album for easier viewing...

Click here

[Swampy]

Thank you Makeover for putting up the image gallery. It sure makes comparisons easier, but not the decisioin! :-)

1. Soleah
2. dougcowell
3. daviskw
4. printmeister

[printmeister]

Well, this was really difficult... every entry I looked at seemed to alter my perception of the previous one!

Please bear in mind that i'm a 'non-expert' at this..! (Colourising AND voting..!)
All the entries were great, considering the the amount of detail in the original.



1 - northernshadow - The cooler colouring of the background seems to enhance the flesh tones of the subjects.

2 - Peter S - I liked the tonal balance and muted colours...only the brides 'punky' haircut stopped me from putting this at no. 1

3 - Daviskw - The warmth and richness appealed to me on this one

4 - soleah - Nice detail... background doesn't overpower subject

5 - cazubi - Liked the muted colours...and I really wanted the 'floozy' to be a real 'black sheep' guest!

Well done to everyone, it was really difficult to come up the top 5.

[Doug Colwell]

Given the amount of green in this pic it's not surprising that green would leak into un-intended areas (like faces and hair). First and second were picked on this basis even though a good argument could probably be made that a green caste could be expected in a room full of green. Most of the pics had stray greens (mine included) and I'm guessing this effect would have been lessened if the people were masked off and/or coloured last.

1. Soleah
2. Cazubi
3. Twinbnj
4. Lorraine
5. Littlecoo

[cazubi]

Kudos to everyone who worked on this one. I looked for a good restoration as well as colorization. Here are the five that I felt came closest.

1.soleah
2.dougcolwell
3.twinbnj
4.littlecoo
5.lorraine

Nice work everyone.

Cathy

[Littlecoo]

Well this was a tough call, I think everyone should get a star for tackling this one!

1. Soleah
2. dougcolwell
3. Lorraine
4. Cazubi
5. PhotoB

Well done everyone!

[Lorraine]

Everyone did a great job in this difficult contest. Congratulations to all of you. Thanks, makeovermagic, for the album.

My votes are based on the final photo quality, reconstruction of missing the background and colorization:

1. Soleah -- Beautiful work to bring out the crispness and clarity of the photo. Colorization and background details are excellent. The bride’s dress is awesome.

2. Cazubi – Background restoration is detailed and extremely well done as is the photo quality and colorization.

3. twinbnj – Good work in maintaining the clarity of the photo and very nice colorization.

4. Doug Colwell – The photo quality is excellent and colorization is good.

5. Littlecoo – Great work on the photo quality. Colorization is good.

Lorraine

[TwinbNJ]

Koodos to all that entered! Very difficult challange.

1 - Soleah - clean, wonderful color.

2 - Lorraine - great detail and crisp restoration.

3 - Cazubi - very nice colors and tone.

4 - Littlecoo - good color and restoration.

5 - Doug Colwell - great job on the clearity and color.

[Peter S]

1 Photob
2 Dougcolwell
3 Lorraine
4 Twinbnj
5 Soleah

Very difficult this when its down to personal prefrences well done all for trying, this was not easy at all.

[Northernshadow]

1. Lorraine
2. PhotoB
3. Soleah
4. Doug Colwell
5. Cazubi

[soleah]

My vote:
1. Cazubi
2. Doug Colwell
3. Lorraine
4. Littlecoo
5. Photob

This contest is a test not only on skill but on patience, maybe even more so. Anybody who participated here have got to be one of the most patient people in the world. Congratulations to all! Well done.

[PhotoB]

Well done everyone. Time well-wasted. LOL

My votes:
1. Soleah - I would KILL for your sharpening technique!

2. DougColwell- Always a fan of your work.

3. Littlecoo- I love the soft hand-tinted look of your piece.

4. Cazubi- Gotta love the floozy!

5. Northernshadow- Beautiful work on the rug- and I love the cooler colors on the wall. Just added that extra spark that pushed you into my top 5.

[Sean2]

1 littlecoo: nice clean up and soft pastel colours, in keeping with a hand-painting - nicely done

2 Soleah: nice sharp picture retouch and grain removal - how did you manage the grain removal?? Very nice, colours just a little strong for me

3 Gary Richardson: grain removal and technique

4. twinjn: nice colorizing and grain removal

5. Doug C. execution, completeness and color

sean

Grain/noise removal played a big part in this one- well done everyone!

[Gary Richardson]

Votes for June Contest

Hard one to judge, so I voted mostly on the impression they had on me.

• 1st Soleah Had the most natural feel of all the entries, with a well chosen colour palette.
• 2rd Twin BNJ Liked this a lot, and it was close between this and Soleah as to which got top place. Personal taste, and a slightly sharper image by Soleah determined the order I chose.
• 3rd Lorraine Image seemed to have a predominantly pinky tinge and was a little too soft, otherwise beautifully executed.
• 4th Cazubi A little undersaturated, otherwise it would have got 3rd over Lorraine.
• 5th Doug Colwell Would have given this 1st place had it not been for the massive over contrast that had been applied, which ruined an otherwise impeccable job.

[Shalford]

1. Cazubi
2. Soleah
3. Doug Colwell
4. Lorraine
5. PhotoB

[T Paul]

I hope to have the results posted later tonight.

[T Paul]

First off congratulations to ALL that tackled this challenge!!!

And the winner is....Soleah

The Prize:

A Coloriage v.2.0 plugin, donated by AKVIS

Top 5
Soleah - 54
Doug Colwell - 34
Cazubi - 29
Lorraine - 26
TwinbNJ - 17