Critiques - - Critique+suggestions Erasmus Bridge

hardeep · #1 08-25-2006, 02:07 PM

Hi

Please visit http://www.hardeep.name/eb.html and let me know what you think and suggestions.

Thanks
Hardeep

Kraellin · #2 08-25-2006, 02:16 PM

i voted for #2 simply because it makes the bridge itself stand out more. it's simple and high contrast. #3 is good also but puts more emphasis on the background with all t hat color. that's fine if that's what you want but i just liked 2 better. #4 is ok, but seems to be a compromise between color and lighting, giving neither a good show. it also lightens things up too much for the true night shot that this is. #1 is also ok, but just a bit unsharp or dull... needs some punch.

but i'm also going to guess that most folks will vote for #3.

craig

Swampy · #3 08-25-2006, 03:05 PM

Nanners, Craig... #2 seems to be getting all the votes. Folks around here know a good shot when they see one. LOL

Gary Richardson · #4 08-25-2006, 03:47 PM

Personally I prefer it Au Naturelle (No 1). The 2nd one has too many blown out areas for me, I like to see ALL the detail from the original.

But I agree with Craig that No1 needs selectively sharpening a touch.