please critique this photo

[zganie]

this photo had a lot of fine cracks which you probably will not see here becaue of the size but please take a look and give me your opinion

thanks zganie

[Mchilly]

I see some part that wasn't clone enough, since you made it black n white it wasn't noticeable in the first glance. But indeed it look good!

[docilebob]

Other than a few very minor details that is very well done.

[Alison]

Originally Posted by zganie

this photo had a lot of fine cracks which you probably will not see here becaue of the size but please take a look and give me your opinion

thanks zganie

Just looks a little bit flat to me. Not sure if my effort is much better.

[Cassidy]

zganie, to my eye, this looks a lovely faithful rebirth