please give some honest feed back and opinions

[happymind]

hi ive recently completed this project for a photoshop creative mag tutorial

feedback welcome i know i have aoot of work to do before im any good

still go to practice cubed

ps
i ve also found some work doing restoration in a printers - first job doing this so wish me luck

thankyou b

[Nezbitten]

Honest opinion, I can still see the crease mark in the top left corner. I am not sure if you applied a dust and scratch filter or you "patched" out the cracks. But using the patch tool here would not have taken very long and should not leave any tell tale light lines where the creases were.

[alisty]

Also, right side where it looks like you smudged out the wall, I think a stamp tool would work better in this area.

I think a little more time working on cleaning up the surfaces, like the wall, would really clean this image up.

Over all , good start.

[happymind]

thanks at nezbitten i see what you mean i did a surface blur on there faces - you cant tell from these images but there was a lot of dust on them and finer cracks and creases
cheers whats the point of having an opinion if its not honest eh -at altisy point taken clone stamp was actually used here although i could have extended the wall