I really like the pumpkin on the right. You utilized the lines of the pumpkin and the wrinkles on the face extremely well. The color adjustment is a pretty close match too, which really helps the face to blend in seamlessly with the pumpkin.
Now the left pumpkin doesn’t look as natural…but hey what pumpkin with a bloody face, eyes and teeth does (smile). I think the problem here is the dark outline around the face. It does not blend in as well with the pumpkin and is more obviously that it has been added.
Still a great entry and definitely one pumpkin patch I prefer to avoid!
Kudos for being the first to tackle this challenge!
~T