Oh nuts... would you look at that. Now the mailbox is really "washed out."
What do to?
1. Duplicate the Background and drag the new layer to the top of the layer stack. ("Oh no. This is what we started with!")
2. Click the "add layer mask" icon at the bottom of the Layers Palette (white thumbnail appears).
3. While holding down the CTRL key, click I. (CTRL + I) This will "invert" the layer mask thumbnail -- white to black. Presto... original image is gone, but there's that ugly, washed out mailbox again.
4. Click X key to change the foreground color to white.
5. If you have
PS 5 or 6 select the Airbrush from the tools palette. If you're a PS7 user, select the brush tool and click the Airbrush icon in the tool bar. Set pressure / flow / opacity low (25%-35% or so).
6. Start airbrushing over the mailbox to restore some original color and texture to the sides. If you want to get a little fancy, you can adjust the opacity setting as you paint the sides -- giving the illusion of edges that were lost in the original image.
COOL TRICK: To paint or erase or clone or heal or whatever in a perfectly stright line:
* With your tool of choice selected, click where you want to start to paint, erase, clone, whatever
* Then while holding down the SHIFT key, click the "end point." Photoshop will draw a perfectly straight line from the initial click to the second one.
7. To give the restored birdhouse color a little body, I added some "noise" (Noise > Add Noise): Settings: 7, Gaussian.
OK... Enough. Time to go watch Survivor.
I know one thing: It won't be ME who gets voted off the island tonight!