Quote:
|
Originally Posted by quail I'm a new member. I am so inspired and impressed with the visual display, variety of interpetations and ability to manipulate photo imagery. The butterfy was stunning. I would like to throw the question out.....if you were starting your careers over now, which softwear programs would you purchase? I have a painting background. There seem to be many combinations and levels from Photoshop Elements, PS8, PSCS to Painter 8----
Like to keep softwear purchases under 1 K. S |
Hello, and W-E-L-C-O-M-E, Quail. Glad you found us.
Regarding software acquisitions (given your painting background)...
If you're pretty much a sketch/draw/paint from scratch type of person, I'd say Painter 8 would be all you'd need for openers.
If you want to manipulate photos:
* I'd buy an older version of Photoshop, say, 5.0 or 5.5 for < $100 on eBay. Then, at your convenience##, I'd acquire a Photoshop 7 or CS upgrade for $100-$150 = full blown Photoshop for $250 -- a considerable savings over buying the full-priced standard package. This is perfectly legit and a lot of people do it -- who know how to.
* Then I'd get the Painter 8 upgrade. If you already have Photoshop, you can get Painter 8 (upgrade) for about $200 less than the regular package. No loss in functonality. Works fine. (That's what I did.)
Why both?
* While there is some functional overlap, each has strengths the other can't touch.
* Photoshop can't touch Painter when it comes to natural media brush stroke effects, esp. acrylics, oils, impasto and watercolors.
* Painter can't touch Photoshop when it comes to overall control over images. Photoshop also has a functionalty called "actions," which are scripts that can be recorded and played back. (Photoshop Elements can be modified to play [some] actions, but you cannot record actions in Photoshop Elements. Painter has no action functionality at all.)
* While you could get Photoshop Elements 2.0 (less expensive than Photoshop), you'd lose out on being able to install the Painter 8 upgrade, which requires Photoshop. So you could have Photoshop Elements + Painter 8 (full edition) for slightly more than Full Photoshop CS + Painter 8 upgrade.
## I say "at your convenience" because Photoshop and Painter are not trivial programs to learn. There would be no immediate need to upgrade because there would be more than enough to learn with Photoshop 5 or 5.5.
Neither Photoshop or Painter is intuitive by any stretch of the imagination and you should mentally budget a couple hundred bucks +/- each on books, videos or training of some sort. (Suggestion: Look into
www.eclecticacademy.com for some very reasonably priced, well organized, meaty content classes.)
Once you get into it, it's great fun! Hope I've encouraged, not discouraged you. By all means ask more questions if you like.
Again, welcome.
~Danny~
(Note: If you reply to this, I will start a "new thread" (with the related posts so far) since we're talking more about software recommendations than than the butterfly pics. No big deal.)