| Re: Skin Retouching - Feedback the arguement/discussion over skin color is an old one. and yes, monitor calibration does play a part. so do color profiles, which is probably why you're seeing differences between the two programs, maureen. some programs display natively in sRGB, others in a different profile. this can make a difference.
but aside from calibration and profiles, you also have the lighting within the image and that can make a huge difference as well. dark lighting will tend to show reds more. fllorescent will show a different way and incandescant and natural sunlight yet other ways. and this is color i'm talking about, not just brights and darks.
if you look at the new fad, HDRI environment lighting, you'll notice that programs using this will tend to come with different 'environments' for use to filter the lighting of an image. these can be quite dramatic changes, affecting both the lights and darks and the coloration.
so, the upshot here is, your image is fine as far as the skin color. lighting and enviroment would easily account for the colors you've used. and, it looks fine on my monitor. yes, it's a touch on the red side, but that, to me, is natural with that lighting. in fact, when i frame just the facial skin, there's quite a bit of yellow in there. |