what the best retouch

[dodezaine]

I know that they are in different photos, but later all they are
equal, same tone of skin, etc.

http://www.zero3design.com/viamedi/news_37.jpg
http://www.zero3design.com/viamedi/news38.jpg

Remembering that it is fashion, not book, the colors can and must be
modified and are for winter 2009 (south america).

I take the photos too, coments will be wellcome, regarding composition, etc.

Hugs

[blom]

Second shot is the best if you ask me...

[jiraw]

I think the Second pic is good.

[L33t]

I think second picture is too cold.... 4600K? -__- blueish you know. I like first one

[lurch]

Like L33t, I like the coloring in the first one. Factoring in the fact that eventually color is supposed to be matched between the two, I still like the first one. The composition seems more real. And I'm not sure that matching the color balance would work for either one. The first one seems to me to be naturally warm in tone, and making it cooler would look strange. The second one could be a little warmer, but is still naturally cool. It's up to the art director to decide what color temperature he wants his winter look to be. I'd pick warm, but that's just me.