Can you spot manipulation?

[nebulaoperator]

Hello everyone. I have recently did manipulation. Can you spot it?
later I will upload original. It is very heavy manipulation I would say so.

[Pari Retouch]

I do recognize that this is manipulated as the boy standing next to the girl doesn't seems to like he is really standing there.

[nebulaoperator]

Can you be more specific about the boy please. Right direction

[TopiToo]

His neck does not look right, is it his body? and the shadow from the jacket on the chair is not complete.

[nebulaoperator]

It is not his body. Shadow was left alone as it is. Tell me about his neck please. Glad getting some responses

[TopiToo]

Originally Posted by nebulaoperator

It is not his body. Shadow was left alone as it is. Tell me about his neck please. Glad getting some responses

to me but its only my opinion, the chain/neck rhs looks odd.

[nebulaoperator]

mAYBE LIGHTING? Chain is original bay the way just like the neck

[iDad]

to me it's the girls neck and check area that do not look right and chain possible whole head replacement

[nebulaoperator]

iDad you are the first to mentioned girls neck. Hmmm interesting. And what do you mean check area?

[iDad]

cheek....... my bad near lip

[nebulaoperator]

Tell me what is wrong with her cheek?

[iDad]

that resolution is a big guessing game but it looks like a scare just left of her lip area or the residue of blending 2 different skin textures

[nebulaoperator]

It just an artifact. That area is clean.

[iDad]

also the guys hand on here hip looks to be off in color, the edges of her jacket sleeve (left arm)and shadow look to dark

[daygraphics]

Looks like maybe the fella is not real fella that was there. Maybe a head replacement from the neck up. I any event... not too shabby. Hot girl!

[daygraphics]

Maybe the whole guy wasn't there. Could be a combo guy, Someone's body with a jacket and someone else's head (maybe yours).

[nebulaoperator]

You know finger tips tend to get red, maybe hot maybe cold or sweaty. good guess anyway.

[iDad]

the resolution hide many things .comeon spell the beans already lol

[nebulaoperator]

True about resolution. Without it hard job would be.

[TopiToo]

Originally Posted by nebulaoperator

It is very heavy manipulation I would say so.

you replaced his head that was all?

[nebulaoperator]

Yes. Only head.

[nebulaoperator]

Thank you everyone.

[Pari Retouch]

Originally Posted by nebulaoperator

Can you be more specific about the boy please. Right direction

I think I was specific already
The boy in person doesn't seems to be standing behind her, its not about neck or nose
I think lighting on his face was the biggest hint that this is manipulated otherwise the whole picture looks fine.

[nebulaoperator]

I did not know what made you think his is not real. i have corrected lighting on his face. It was too bright and too saturated in my opinion. Hus beck was too light too. When I do this kind of project I most want to hear what strikes first to people and then I do correction. After hours by computer everything just gets too same.

[nebulaoperator]

thIS should be more or less final version of manipulation.Also man's jacket and shirt were extended down.

[renata]

I admit that I wouldn't have guessed. Only after you let on do I compare them and think that the new face actually looks like a "nicer" human being than the original...

A more "human" (not photoshop) analysis: if the new photo was original, would note that the original couple are wearing co-ordinated outfits and hair. They have actually SET OUT to look like a couple. In the new version, the guy is an independant being with his own hair and unconcerned expression. Maybe he's a millionaire in his own right? Nah, then he wouldn't bother copying her clothes. Her bodyguard? Nah, she wouldn't let a bodyguard wear that. Her toyboy? Maybe, but he doesn't look stupid enough... Her brother?...

I'm sorry, I couldn't resist! Great job!

[nebulaoperator]

just love your analysis. Though I liked new guy more then former I would not come with such analysis regarding his character. I also like the fact that you touch co-ordinated outfits theme and spotted that, following that comes his personality analysis

[spotter]

I thought it was the female's waist line that was changed as she looks like she has a pocket in her skin but I guess that is just an optical illusion.

[nebulaoperator]

It is a complement to me.

[firinprogress]

the first thing that caught my eye was the head. It was definitely out of place due to the lighting of the camera and the sharpness of the male head and the surrounding. but other than that, I couldn't spot anything else.. however, i was surprised about the shirt. it was definitely a clean touch. but yea. cool way to interact with people on the forums!