No announcement yet.

Asking for a critique?


  • Ant
    started a blog post Asking for a critique?

    Asking for a critique?

    Some thoughts.

    1. Callus up your skin. If you want honest feedback, prepare to get your bubble potentially skewered.

    2. Have YOU critiqued your work? Honestly? The key to doing work well is being highly critical of your OWN work. Compare and contrast. Be brutal with yourself before slugging it off on someone else. Look at things as a whole. Look at them close and far. What works? What doesn't work? Would this suffice as a first round for a client, or have you missed the point entirely and only concentrated on smoothing that skin and left out all the needed color moves, masking, hair, etc? Is this to be compared to something done in the real world? Really, how well does it compare? Is your original shit to begin with? Are you trying to polish a turd? In the real world, the Art Director won't even comment nor mark-up your proof if you missed the basics. "Why am I even seeing this if it's not ready? Stop wasting my time"

    3. Who exactly are you asking for opinions? This could go to the pimply young teen that wants to be a model: "Everyone is always telling me how pretty I am and that I should model" - Are they, or are your friends, mother and grandma telling you. Ask yourself what they know and look in the mirror again while holdiing up that picture of Giselle.
      You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Related Topics


      Critique is welcome
      by KriCoFOTODESIGN
      One of our newest retouching works. CC ist welcome and helpful!

      sorry for my english, its not the best

      02-28-2014, 05:52 AM
    • CJ Swartz
      Advice on giving a good critique
      by CJ Swartz
      I've stated before that doing a good critique of a work is difficult for me -- it's an excellent exercise in looking for the important elements of an image, and deciding what works well and what does not.

      A few of our members are already experienced at giving critiques, and for the rest...
      06-01-2003, 03:17 PM
    • blue dog
      Is This Where I File My Complaints?
      by blue dog
      I joined this site a few months ago to try and improve my skills with a goal of being able to make some small living from it. Prior to finding Retouch Pro, I thought that I was ready to go, but a little tour of people's work here convinced me that I had a long way to go.

      So, its not all...
      08-10-2006, 11:02 AM
    • Mer-Cee
      Critique needed
      by Mer-Cee
      Hello Community,

      its me again..

      here is one of my latest retouching images (before/after) i would like to share with you.
      but this image is NOT done yet and i know i still have to learn alot.

      please give me your constructive critique and suggestions....
      06-25-2013, 02:56 AM
    • G. Couch
      "What is this Forum?...and who should give critiques?"
      by G. Couch
      This is basically a forum for getting honest and direct feedback on your work. This can be any type of image from a Restoration to Photo Art. A critique is meant to be a tool for learning and if you post in this forum you will hopefully receive constructive feedback on your image's strengths and weaknesses,...
      06-01-2003, 03:48 PM