Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Collage or Montage

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Collage or Montage

    This is just to test members views on the difference (if any) between these words.

    I was always under the impression that a collage was a picture made up of bits and pieces of other pictures (such as some of Greg's pictures). In this case the components lose their original identity when viewing the picture as a whole.

    A montage on the other hand is a grouping of pictures in which each of the individual pictures still maintain their original identity (such as my Kaokoveld montage). There may be pleasing lines and groupings, but each picture stands on its own (this maybe an example)

    I see some dictionaries make these words synonymous, but I feel this, is incorrect as is in the case of making information and knowledge synonymous.

  • #2
    I personally see collage as a subset of montage.
    Learn by teaching
    Take responsibility for learning

    Comment


    • #3
      Al, when I think about it, I make the same distinction you do. And yet I often find myself using the words interchangably. (Not that I use them THAT often! ) As I'm learning more, I do try to make a distinction though.

      But then I wonder, how would you classify the photo that Sandra did for her client - merging the daughters and mother into one photo? (I just call that a "manipulation" to avoid the whole issue. )

      Jeanie

      Comment


      • #4
        You're right Jeanie, in Sanda's case a manipulation is the best word to use. What would one use in Lisa's second montage/collage manipulation?

        Doug, I think your definition is the best.

        Comment


        • #5
          We came >this< close to being the site for "retouching, restoration, and montage".
          Learn by teaching
          Take responsibility for learning

          Comment


          • #6
            Wow, isn't life strange.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by BigAl
              What would one use in Lisa's second montage/collage manipulation?
              I would call that "art".
              Jeanie

              Comment


              • #8
                I've always thought of a collage as elements pasted together to form a new picture. The old way was to actually take hard copy and cut and paste, interweaving the outlines and overlapping them, sometimes even in a shape outline as a "frame" to go with the theme of the subject matter.

                These days, with computers, I think of collage as having elements combined with use of blend modes and overlays and fades and such.

                I think I hold the same distinction between the two as BigAl.

                Merely an opinion.

                Comment

                Related Topics

                Collapse

                • Diabetic
                  Where to Begin? (Senior Pictures)
                  by Diabetic
                  I ended up buying my Senior Pictures, but I do wish to try and create my own for fun as well.

                  I have a beginner to moderate experience with Photoshop, but usually I do not edit pictures of people and am confused as to how to start on this.

                  Attached is a couple of pictures...
                  04-30-2010, 07:36 PM
                • Londonjohn
                  Montages Help Please
                  by Londonjohn
                  Hi all,

                  Could someone help please.
                  I want to create a montage of old photos I have restored.
                  At the moment all I have tried is using the clone tool.
                  Is there a set way of doing montages?
                  Things like setting the image size and resolution, using layers etc...
                  09-11-2004, 05:46 AM
                • yamaha83
                  how to combine pictures?
                  by yamaha83
                  just starting to get my feet wet in photoshop and lightroom 2 and and my fiances sister really liked some pictures i did of her 2 kids in lightroom 2 and wanted me to combine a couple pics of the kids with another image kind of like a collage... the thing is that im not sure on the best way to do this?...
                  12-15-2009, 09:19 AM
                • dipech
                  Any collage mavens out there?
                  by dipech
                  Hi Everyone!

                  I am wondering if anyone is up on the best way to do the kind of collage I am attaching?

                  I know this kind of project can be done fairly easily in Quark Express with picture boxes and preset columns but it seems that Quark only lets you make documents up to...
                  04-28-2004, 08:50 PM
                • Hapsmig
                  Can any one help!
                  by Hapsmig
                  Hi

                  I am going to hold a seminar for some of the biggest companies i denmark. The seminar is about the good picture. The importens that we use the best possible pictures for our commercial. My plan is that i will show some retouching and some manipulation. But almost every pictures that...
                  03-07-2008, 07:54 AM
                Working...
                X