No announcement yet.

Digital "Art"?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Digital "Art"?

    I don't consider myself as having much artistic ability, but I've seen what I think are outstanding "art" images on this site. But what makes a digital image "art"? Is it applying the correct filter to make the image look like a heavy oil painting, or other forms of art? Does a digital artist need the knowledge of how to create the "look" from scratch, or can they do it by using a Photoshop action that someone else might have created? What is your personal opinion on digital "art" and digital "artists"?


  • #2
    Ed - this is a difficult one!

    Art is something you create - the tools that you use are just a means to an end. Whether you are creating a wood sculpture, painting or producing something digitally - what you create is art.

    Art can be to someone something divine and to another a piece of trash - what ever the persons reaction does not make something any more or any less Art.

    I think digital art has opened the whole image creating field up and made it more accessable to more and more people.

    Filters can be used by two different people with the same image with different results - I think that is what makes the viable as part of 'digital art'.

    Its almost like a vision that people are creating. I find the main difficulty is transfereing what is on the screen on to some kind of solid medium.

    May be another part of the question is when does it become art - while it is on the screen or when its outputed to paper/canvas?

    Sorry if I went off the rails


    • #3

      You didn't think I'd give you an easy one, did you? And, no, you didn't go off the rails. It's all connected.



      • #4
        Digital art is no different than any other form of's mostly a matter of opinion and intention. If I spend hours on a digital image is it by default more of a work of "Art" than say an image that simply had a filter applied to it? Probably. But it's like comparing paint-by-numbers to a Rembrandt. They are created for entirely different reasons. If filters bring someone who has never been able to paint some joy and happiness then I am all for it...but if you want to hang work in a gallery and want it to be considered as "serious" art, it does take a bit more than a few filters to create an image.


        • #5
          I was just about to post a new thread, "Where's Greg?" Glad to see you back.



          • #6
            I think art lies in the creation of the original piece of work. Retouching is no more than a mechanic changing the oil!


            • #7
              Hey all

              First of all let me say what a fantastic site this is. I've been doing retouching work for people for a while now as a hobby and this place has been very helpful (yes, I'm guilty of lurking!).

              I've seen this question come up in a few different forms before and I'd like to share my answer to a recent one "What is digital art all about?"

              I make no distinction between digital, drawing, photography, painting, ect. in terms of art. The way I see it, the only way various mediums differ is in the technique used to arive at the final product. One has to know how to effectively apply the techniques relative to the chosen medium in order to create a well composed image. So, I think I'll take out the 'digital' and just ask "What is art really all about." and to me, its about self expression.

              I would also like to add a link here to my favorite digital artist (you'll love his work)




              • #8
                Welcome to retouchPRO. Glad you decided to stop lurking and introduce your self - allways good to see another face.

                I look forward to seeing some of your work in the gallery and challenges.



                Related Topics


                • catherine k
                  My Digital Art on Shutterstock-using Photoshop
                  by catherine k
                  Hi, just want to share. I do lots of retouching as well as drawing using photoshop. You might want to check out some of my digital art on Shutterstock.

                  03-23-2011, 12:03 AM
                • Doug Nelson
                  But is it "Art"?
                  by Doug Nelson
                  Not a real topic of information or controversy here, just some stuff that's been buzzing around my brain recently and I thought I'd jot it down to see if anyone has any thoughts on the matter.

                  This business of inkjet companies listing 200 years as "archival" bugs me. The fact...
                  12-18-2001, 02:58 AM
                • winwintoo
                  Here's your chance to defend your art form.
                  by winwintoo
                  I'm from the "I don't know anything about art, but I know what I like" crowd.

                  I just had a discussion with my son the artsy university student. One of his classes is looking at art and computers and the internet and all that. I'm not sure what they are trying to prove, but he...
                  03-05-2003, 08:04 PM
                • Tareq
                  Art in Photography.....Discussion
                  by Tareq
                  Hey all,

                  I would like to ask about: What is art in photography?
                  How can you define Photography Fine Art?
                  When you can say about a photo that it is art?
                  What is the standard or qualification for the photo to be an art?
                  Who can tell about any photo that it...
                  02-03-2009, 04:35 PM
                • mridangini
                  Need ideas-Transporting digital art without damage
                  by mridangini
                  I am a professional exhibitor of canvas art and I organize various kind of exhibition around the country. But the main problem is: when I have to transport these are getting damaged through transportation. I am looking for any safe carriers for the arts. I prefer something on wheels and portable that...
                  02-24-2009, 10:40 PM