No announcement yet.

Real or fake??

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Real or fake??

    This has been a very bad year for forest fires in the western states and provinces and there have been many pictures posted showing the destruction. I've had this one sent to me by several people but I'm not sure it's ligitimate.

    What do you think??

    See it here


  • #2
    Hi !

    I don't have a clue, I took a close look and the lighting looks pretty convincing. The only area of lighting I question is the grasses on the left have a soft light coming from the right instead of from the direction of the fire. But if there was sun filtered through clouds of smoke that was bright enough coming from the right it would make sense, and the dark area in the bottom right corner would be consistant with that.

    So I am left with a question - with the noise of a fire, would deer stand in the middle of a stream and just watch (they look like they are looking towards us, but is just my sense - I can't really tell which way they are looking.



    • #3
      It looks like a great shot if it is real. I looked at the histogram on it and it seems normal. So it is either a real good shot or a real good manipulation. I don't know.


      • #4

        As far as I've been able to determine, this is a real photo. It was taken in the summer of 2000 though, so if you've gotten e-mail indicating otherwise, that info is probably false. Here's a couple links about it:

        Roger, that first link mentions something about animal behavior during wildfires.



        • #5
          Thanks for the information Jeanie!

          I thought it odd that the deer would just be standing there, but I guess they know what they're doing

          Take care Margaret


          • #6
            I know this thread's old and your image is no longer hosted, but I'm guessing you're talking about this:


            • #7
              That is the one - I had found some indications that the picture was real, but didn't see the write-up on Snopes. Thanks for the link.



              • #8
                Just for interest, here are larger versions... copies of the originals the site says.


                Related Topics


                • Mark Adams
                  Which one of these is "better"?
                  by Mark Adams
                  Working on a project for this week. I've got two versions of this. Version #1 is a more faithful adaptation of the original, but the lighting is wrong.

                  FDNY globe #1 is here

                  Version #2 is lit correctly, but looks "funny" if you're familiar with the orginal....
                  09-06-2004, 09:30 AM
                • wmchauncey
                  I've pretty well maxed out my left brain in creati
                  by wmchauncey
                  I've pretty well maxed out my left brain in creating this and my artistic right brain is a failure.
                  Each of the orbs is on it's own layer as is the galaxy thingy...would like some help in their layout on the background.
                  Suggestions would really be appreciated...thanks!

                  12-11-2014, 12:57 PM
                • macdool
                  Fake ocean: Look real?
                  by macdool
                  Hi I took these photos, did the usual contrast and neutralize. I might have saturated it abit to much but it looks okay on the A4 prints I did.

                  What I realy want to talk about is the water. I created a new image put alot of noise on it, embossed the separations all in different directions...
                  12-17-2010, 03:22 AM
                • winwintoo
                  Real or Photoshopped??
                  by winwintoo
                  I came across these images - believe it or not, I was looking for beading patterns and I wondered just how real they are.

                  I'll let you all have a look and then give you my interpretation - not that I'm any expert!

                  11-11-2005, 05:57 PM
                • fstr21
                  Retouching real estate?
                  by fstr21
                  While I was asking around about the best ways to try to make some side cash with restoring / retouching a friend of mine suggested retouching real estate agents' pictures of houses before they put them on their respected sites. anyone have any thoughts on this? I cant imagine it would be anything that...
                  06-03-2010, 05:07 PM