No announcement yet.

Question: What is "Thread hijacking"?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Question: What is "Thread hijacking"?

    Thread hijacking is a term I just found for an old problem: radical departure from the topic of a thread. I guess a lot of folks view a thread as a discussion between them and one or two others, like a little chat room. But it just ain't so.

    A lot of users join because they find a thread so compelling they feel they must get involved. Plus the vast majority of users sign on, hit "view new threads" and read the few of interest to them. But, if the thread is titled for one topic and changes a few posts in, chances are only a very few people are ever going to see it, however marvelous and useful it ends up being.

    Also, it isn't fair to the originator of the thread, since many are loath to interupt an ongoing conversation, even if it's just to return to the title topic.

    And you can hijack your own thread. I guess the thought process is something like "I started this thread, I'll discuss what I please". This is self-defeating, since once a thread is off-topic most will lose interest and never return, even if it drifts back.
    Learn by teaching
    Take responsibility for learning

  • #2
    Very true Doug, now if I can just point out that....


    • #3
      Re: Question: What is "Thread hijacking"?

      While bumping in excess can defeat the purpose, if you find an older post and have something legitimate to add or ask it can sometimes lead to the thread finding a new life and being seen by many that wouldn't otherwise.


      • #4
        Re: Question: What is "Thread hijacking"?

        a thread is like a paragraph in a book. it has a fairly specific topic. if you change topics you start a new paragraph. pretty simple.

        on the other hand, i've hijacked my share of threads, both here and on other forums. one gets insprired by something in a thread and just wants to comment. it's mostly non-sequitir to the current topic but doesnt really warrant a new thread. then, along come 10 more folks who comment on your off-topic comment and the thread is hijacked

        you could also liken it to a conversation within a group. there is a topic being discussed and someone else comes along and changes the topic or maybe just shifts it a bit. it's perfectly ok to bring the topic back on-topic. most folks generally will go 'oh, sorry' and let their topic drop.


        Related Topics


        • Doug Nelson
          Question: What is a "Bump"?
          by Doug Nelson
          The vast majority of forum users rely on the "new posts" page to determine what they'll read. For various reasons, this means perfectly useful and interesting threads can sometimes die an early death. Placing a post in these threads will "bump" them, and make them appear in the "new...
          05-05-2002, 11:39 PM
        • DJ Dubovsky
          Threads going unnoticed
          by DJ Dubovsky
          I know I'm not the only one who has noticed that every now and then someone will post a thread that will go totally unnoticed. I don't know exactly why this happens but I thought I would bring it to everyones attention. If you post a thread and notice no one answers it or no on responds to one of...
          12-17-2001, 09:31 PM
        • Doug Nelson
          The forums aren't a chat room
          by Doug Nelson
          Perhaps not enough forum posters realize (or care) that they aren't just talking to the one or three people that respond back in their thread. No, they're actually talking to thousands of people every day.

          Yet they bounce around from topic to topic within a single thread as if they were...
          11-15-2007, 06:05 PM
        • Doug Nelson
          Question: What is "Threadophobia"?
          by Doug Nelson
          The fear of starting new threads has unknown origins, but is believed similar to the fear of raising a hand in class. The only known cure is acclimatization therapy (ie: doing it while reminding yourself that you're among friends, nothing bad will happen, etc.).
          05-06-2002, 01:23 PM
        • OlProfBear
          Violated the Unwritten Law? or what ...
          by OlProfBear
          Last Saturday I posted:

          ... and not ONE person responded, even to say something rude.

          Now, I figure I must have violated the Unwritten Law or maybe even a Written Law that lurks here...
          11-18-2004, 05:48 PM