No announcement yet.

Toughest ever: Please Critque

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Toughest ever: Please Critque

    Well, I learned alot about what works and what doesn't on this one. A lot of experimentation went into solving its problems. I am intentionally not going to tell you everything that I did. The first tumb is my original scan. The second is a cross-polarized copy ($75!!!) - big disappointment. The third is my 'final' pending your suggestions.

    The silverizing (see its lower-left corner) is only part of its problem. There are also light streaks that may have been due to the camera or something else. I spent hours trying to decipher what was real vs defects when I realized that there is a second photo that is paritially imposed over this one - I assume they were stacked and deteriorization caused one to bleed into the other.

    OK. I dodged and burned alot! I tried to find a technique to short-cut that but never found anything useful. Doing that did lead me to discover more 'real' features. Somethings had to be reconstructed using partials of a feature that I could not completely bring out.

    The face. This is uh - "handsome" woman. Maybe a little is due to defects in the photo, its hard to tell, but not much. I did restore her eye, dodge some dark shadows, and applied a tiny bit of degrunging. I am concerned about cleaning her up to much because most of those are really hers.

    Question: Did I do too much? Not enough?

    I am anxious to hear your opinions.
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Re: Toughest ever: Please Critque

    Excellent job, Blue Dog! Better than I could have done. I just don't have the patience for that kind of work.

    I don't know how a customer could expect much more, but I'm sure there are some experts here in RTP who might have deeper thoughts than my limited ability. :-)

    Suffice it to say, I'd be pleased as punch if I were a paying customer.


    Related Topics


    • G Mantero
      Critique me, please-hit me with your best shot :)
      by G Mantero
      See attached picture. In general, I'm pretty happy with it, but have some concern about the boy's clothes blowing out a bit. I've done some selective dodging/burning to help with problem areas, but am not happy with the results.

      FYI: This client specifically requested that the picture...
      07-18-2002, 10:01 AM
    • Tim Whitney
      C&C – Photo by Jasz
      by Tim Whitney
      Hi, I have been lurking around the site for quite a few months now trying to absorb as much as possible. I am looking for serious critiques and comments on this retouch. What did I overlook, what could be better, what should I have not done at all? Please be honest, I am not here just to have some fun...
      03-31-2008, 09:46 PM
    • Jakaleena
      How Much Artistic License?
      by Jakaleena
      Ok, ethics question here...

      The scenario is that you're doing a restoration job for a client. How much artistic license do you take? And what reasons do you have for drawing the line at that particular place? What is fair game for changing, and what do you consider "sacred"?...
      05-05-2002, 12:12 PM
    • imann08
      Tough image... for me.
      by imann08
      This was quite a tough image for me. I have a tough time knowing where that line is of retaining original texture and blurring too much. I paid close attention to that in this one but still don't think I got it right. I was looking to see what some of you would do with such an image. It's got bad stain...
      08-07-2006, 12:08 AM
    • RichardBrackin
      Before and After - Winter Scene
      by RichardBrackin
      I suppose this is the right place for this ...

      I haven't been a member here long but I have enjoyed looking at everyone's work and wanted to share with you a job we did recently for a series of airport wall murals in Vermont to get your opinions.
      The customer sent us a drum scan...
      06-02-2005, 10:21 AM