Judge me

[jphilsantos]

Please tell me what you think about my retouching. How could I improve it, my goods and bads.

here is the link

https://odesk-prod-att.s3.amazonaws.com/Portfolio%20Items:1251502:ImageUrl?AWSAccessKeyId=1XVAX3FNQZAFC9GJCFR2&Expires=2147483647&Signature=arFgdWX%2FamjqQYPuC%2FBM%2FyRaZAc%3D

Thank you.

[Bressler]

Re: Judge me

There isn't too much edited here.
Good: I like the upped contrast mostly, you did a good job on the arm and the smoothing.

I would remove the toe line on her left foot. There is a distinctive line on her ankles seperating a tonal difference from her legs to her feet, her feet need to be matched in tone to her legs for a more even appearance.

This one is purely opinion but I feel shading on her face is too deep for the scene she is in. It seems too lite outside for her hair to cast such a deep shadow.

[Bressler]

Re: Judge me

Oh yeah also, the people removed in the background is good, but I would also take out the tree or whaever it is that's going straight up through the back of her head.

[Ruzzez]

Re: Judge me

The Sky is white and appears washed out.

[jphilsantos]

Re: Judge me

Thank you for your honest comments I really appreciate it.

[mommyof4qteez]

Re: Judge me

Maybe add some fill light so her face isn't so dark