No announcement yet.

Guidelines - Required Reading before posting!

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Guidelines - Required Reading before posting!

    These are important guidelines to follow when posting in this forum. I am going to ask that prior to posting here, everyone read these and acknowledge that they have, either in this thread or send me a PM...I know that sounds pretty strict but it will hopefully help avoid any situations of posters making personal attacks or "drive-by" posters - individuals who show up, post 30 images at once and then never contribute anything else. Anyone who blatantly disregards the guidelines, engages in personal attacks, or is just consistently rude, will get a very kind warning...followed by not-so-kind action if the behavior continues. Keep in mind however, there is a big difference between honest discussion and rude behavior...

    These are guidelines that apply to giving and receiving a critique-

    DO -
    • make constructive comments.
    • post any photographic image - Restorations, Photo-Art, Retouching (keep in mind that the guidelines that govern the overall site apply here as well.)
    • qualify compliments or criticisms with reasons and give suggestions for improvement.
    • be honest. If you really do not like something, say so!
    • If you post an image, write a basic description of how the image was created. This is very important as it will help others give a more informed opinion and allow everyone to learn.
    • post your skill level. If you have just begun to learn a program like Photoshop, please say so....And if you are giving a critique, keep the skill level of the image creator in mind. No one will benefit if you treat a beginner like a pro or vice versa.
    • Always try to post something positive even if you really dislike an image.
    • ask for things to be explained further if you do not understand someone's comments.
    • keep in mind that opinions are subjective...and a criticism of your work is not an attack on your character.
    • feel free to make any suggestions that you feel would improve this forum!
    • ask before uploading changes to someone's image. This mostly applies to when you see a post by a new member. Some people may take offense to any altering of their images and a quick "is it ok to make and upload changes?" could prevent a confrontation.

    DON'T -
    • engage in personal attacks, or make rude comments
    • make posts that only compliment or only criticize. The fact that you might like an image is wonderful...but please explain why!
    • post every image you have ever created. This forum is really meant for in-depth discussion of be selective about the image you post for critique. It might be your best work and you want to see what other's might be an image that is giving you all sorts of problems... Or perhaps it's an image that is bound for a competition or show and you want to get the opinion of peers. It could even be an image that a client rejected and you want to find out where you went wrong!
    • flood the forum with images. No one is going to respond if you upload 20 images in one day. 1 or 2 images a week is probably a good number. This will allow everyone to see your work and make detailed comments before you post another image.
    • post an image and then not respond to any of the comments. We want a dialogue...not comments that fall on deaf ears or posters who disappear into thin air after uploading.

    These guidelines are a rough idea of how this forum should operate...and will probably be updated and added to. Most of all just keep in mind that this site has developed a reputation as being one of the most helpful on the net and this forum should continue in that spirit.

    Have fun!
    Last edited by G. Couch; 08-10-2003, 10:34 AM.

  • #2
    Just to qualify myself, I've read the guidelines.



    • #3
      Well said Greg!



      • #4
        Couldn't agree more!


        • #5
          I read the guidelines-- I am in full agreement with the above guidelins.


          • #6
            I have also read the guidelines and I'm glad to see this area realized.



            • #7
              I've read the official guidelines, and agree to abide by them.

              I think this forum is an excellent addition to the site, and will be a good learning tool for many of us.

              Greg, you have given us a fine standard of conduct with work with, and a clear method with which to use the forum -- good job!


              • #8


                • #9
                  These are really common sense guidelines. I've read and agree with them.


                  • #10
                    I've read the guidelines and will abide by them. They are plain common sense and courtesy rules that we should all be able to follow quite easily. Again thanks, Greg, for realizing this is needed



                    • #11

                      Seems common sense but nice to see so clearly and definitively stated.
                      I look forward to seeing/hearing how it goes.


                      • #12
                        I've read the guidelines and couldn't agree more, it is just common courtesy. Well stated!



                        • #13
                          Very well said Greg. I agree with everything.


                          • #14
                            Well said, Greg.

                            Does this mean you're going to have to moderate this particular forum before anything gets posted?


                            • #15
                              I AGREE

                              Thanks Greg - I concur and don't have a problem agreeing to abide by these guidelines.



                              Related Topics


                              • G. Couch
                                "What is this Forum?...and who should give critiques?"
                                by G. Couch
                                This is basically a forum for getting honest and direct feedback on your work. This can be any type of image from a Restoration to Photo Art. A critique is meant to be a tool for learning and if you post in this forum you will hopefully receive constructive feedback on your image's strengths and weaknesses,...
                                06-01-2003, 03:48 PM
                              • G. Couch
                                A Gentle Reminder... "compliment only" or "Kudo" posts are discouraged.
                                by G. Couch
                                I know I sound like a real prude... but please remember that posts that only say "Great job!", "I love it!", etc... are not allowed in this forum. You can certainly say all those things in a post, but you are expected to "flesh out" and detail your comments a bit more extensively...explain...
                                06-05-2003, 07:14 PM
                              • Craig Walters
                                Posting Your Image and Works Etiquette
                                by Craig Walters
                                i've done numerous retouches, restores and photo art on i enjoy it. however, there is something that rankles me just a bit from time to time. someone comes in, posts needing help with an image, goes away for a while, comes back and gives maybe a general 'thanks, all', picks up their...
                                07-13-2007, 01:33 AM
                              • DannyRaphael
                                WELCOME to "Tell, Show and Try-it"
                                by DannyRaphael

                                LOOKING FOR THE old self-service MEMBER POSTED MINI-CHALLENGE forum? See Q-A at the bottom of this post.


                                If this is your first time to the Tell, Show and Try-it forum, WEL...
                                07-01-2003, 03:47 AM
                              • CJ Swartz
                                Advice on giving a good critique
                                by CJ Swartz
                                I've stated before that doing a good critique of a work is difficult for me -- it's an excellent exercise in looking for the important elements of an image, and deciding what works well and what does not.

                                A few of our members are already experienced at giving critiques, and for the rest...
                                06-01-2003, 03:17 PM