No announcement yet.

Nude Redux Review

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Nude Redux Review

    I posted this in the gallery but decided to redo it. I spent weeks or months on it(whichever is longer) and would like your opinion. Is it done?
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Overall, a stunning piece of work, Greg. I'm in awe (again) of your talent.

    Here are two things that caught my eye. I don't think they're necessarily "wrong" and I suspect you've already considered them. Wanted to point them out from the perspective of a non-artist for your consideration.

    See the intersection of shadows just below her left elbow? If she and the picture frame are lighted from the same source, seems like the shadows would be a little closer in shade...maybe not the exact shade, but a little closer than shown. On the other hand, maybe not. I'm no shadow expert. Just tossin' that one out there.

    The other area that caught my eye is the very top/left corner of the picture....that little rectangle of wall just to the left of the frame that's "not" shadowed. Seems to me if you had about an inch of "tan wall" along the top of the frame, that corner might not stand out.

    Other than those, I can think of no possible improvements I could possibly suggest.



    • #3
      I thought it was so done, I just thru it together at the end. I though I used the same gray for both shadows but your right, it's not right, and the corner thing too. I'll fix it. Now that's all anyone will see, because you brought it out so early, oh well...........


      • #4
        Very impressive, you are very talented. oops
        Last edited by Sanda; 06-24-2002, 05:01 AM.


        • #5
          Thanks Sandra.

          Looks like we really need a spell checker here, huh?


          • #6
            Well, I have to say it. I like the one in the gallery better...

            The reason is, because she's inside the frame instead of outside it. Because she's obviously not a part of that painting, it makes a statement to me that she has "become" art herself, kind of like an Alice through the looking glass sort of thing. In the new one, she's outside the art looking in, so to speak. The first one (in the gallery) has her more intimately connected with the art itself. The second one reduces her to just a naked lady in front of a painting...

            All just my opinion of course...


            • #7
              Originally posted by Jakaleena
              [B]Well, I have to say it. I like the one in the gallery better...

              The second one reduces her to just a naked lady in front of a painting...
              Jak: but that's what I'm good at, would you prefer a boat? maybe a prop, hulla hoop, dogs are good too.
              your analysis is so philisopical, I can't obsorb it all. So......
              I think I'll keep both, and tune this one up a little.


              Related Topics


              • Canna W
                Problem with shadows I think.
                by Canna W
                I tried to post this pic as a regular pic at flickr, but one of my friends picked up that it was a composite. When I asked her how she knew, she said (re the dogs), "Their paws are not pressed into the grass". Now I did give the dogs shadows, plus I used the smudge tool to pull grass up...
                08-11-2011, 07:47 AM
              • Imhotep
                Self taught
                by Imhotep
                Let the critique begin...
                11-07-2003, 09:02 AM
              • renzoski
                Irrational phobia assignment
                by renzoski
                This is my first post here in retouch pro. This is my latest piece i worked on for my maps/mattes/masks class here at the art institute of fort lauderdale. The teacher asked us to represent any irrational phobias.It probably took me about 15 hours to finish it....I guess the picture speaks for itself.......
                09-22-2005, 02:49 PM
              • venivedi
                Restoring a photo taken about ten years ago
                by venivedi
                The left side image is a requested one at an open retouch & restoration bulletin.

                As you see, it's been kept carelessly and (years ago) scanned image's quality isn't good. But he(requester) said that he can't afford to scan it again.
                By the way, he want her (in the photo) to...
                11-02-2004, 12:16 PM
              • suchyy
                by suchyy
                Here is my last restoration, the picture is from 'challenges' forum but i do not want to post it there as i am not sure if it is completed

                Największa polska sieć blogów profesjonalnych NT

                Please critique.
                03-04-2006, 12:29 PM