I started this thread after thinking about the "critique" discussion. I thought maybe, instead of individual critiques, I would start a thread for "overall" critique discussion.
I just want to add, that for some reason, I am compelled to voice my opinion. So, I hope no one takes offense, or belives it to be anything more than that - just my opinion (and a desire to help).
Here goes....
I think overall, the members are really good at getting out cracks, scratches, and such. The thing that I've noticed though, is that the aftermath from such repairs sometimes looks smeared, blurry, or painted.
From my own experiments, I would guess this is due to the choice of tools used, and the amount of effects applied.
I have read many techniques that recommend Median, Gaussian Blur, and Dust & Scratches. I personally never use these tools as a method for repair, because they seem to destroy the essence of the qualities that make it a "photograph", (and not a a painting).
For me, the number one tool is the "clone" tool. It takes longer, and is indeed, more work, but I think it's worth it.
Ok, enough rambling from me. (P.S, I started cold medication today. Maybe it's gone to my head)
I just want to add, that for some reason, I am compelled to voice my opinion. So, I hope no one takes offense, or belives it to be anything more than that - just my opinion (and a desire to help).
Here goes....
I think overall, the members are really good at getting out cracks, scratches, and such. The thing that I've noticed though, is that the aftermath from such repairs sometimes looks smeared, blurry, or painted.
From my own experiments, I would guess this is due to the choice of tools used, and the amount of effects applied.
I have read many techniques that recommend Median, Gaussian Blur, and Dust & Scratches. I personally never use these tools as a method for repair, because they seem to destroy the essence of the qualities that make it a "photograph", (and not a a painting).
For me, the number one tool is the "clone" tool. It takes longer, and is indeed, more work, but I think it's worth it.
Ok, enough rambling from me. (P.S, I started cold medication today. Maybe it's gone to my head)
Comment