Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Irrecoverable?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Irrecoverable?

    When do you judge an old, faded, damaged photo to be irrecoverable?

    The attached 1978 photo is faded an contains obvious defects of many types. My experience levels with PSP8 and PSE2 are still too small to know if this is a lost cause or not.

    The attached was scanned at 1200 spi and saved as a TIF file. I had to adjust the image to 300 dpi and save as a JPEG (of med quality) to fit the file size limits.

    I have also looked at the color channels, I have tried various levels/histogram/curves combinations. The obvious individual defects pale in comparison to the red/blotch noise in the lower level of the photo (the kids legs, arms, facee, etc.) The lower part of the face of the man on the right (me) seems obliterated. It seems there is no detail anywhere to enhance or recapture.

    I even looked at B/W (desaturated) but things were no more encouraging there. I can do some improvements to be sure but it seems that photos like this are basically lost to the time elements.

    Any comments or advice at this point? I would be most grateful for any coaching.

    Ken

    [Edit: sorry--the photo uploaded was the desaturated version...full version in next message.]
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Full Color for Irrecoverable Photo

    Here is the color version, such as it is....

    Ken
    Attached Files

    Comment


    • #3
      Sorry I would consider the work too time consuming. You would need to virtually rebuild the faces. But then it is up to you to make the final decision

      Comment


      • #4
        The image is far from lost - but I am not saying that this will be easy!

        It will be a labour of love, is this a commercial job or a 'freebie' for family/friends?

        The lower section will probably need rebuilding, but there is nothing too hard to fill in and flesh out here.

        I have seen many challenges at this site which were in much worse shape, not to say that this is a pristine image though. <g>

        Keep in mind that different clients have different expectations - a restoration that you are not happy with may impress them. Or it could go the other way and they hate a job you are proud of. <bg>

        If the job is worth your time/effort - then I think that you may be able to do this image justice.

        Are there any correction areas that are giving you problems or that you could do with alternate methods (noise removal, separate luminance and colour edits or LAB edits, bringing out detail [search the site for adaptive equalize plug in info] etc?)

        Regards,

        Stephen Marsh.

        Comment


        • #5
          Stephen: that is an encouraging message. This is in the "labor of love" category as well as preparation for numerous others like this from the family "photo box". Short of "painting over the whole thing" with paint brushes and smudge tools, I am hoping to get some specific advice. I will post my steps to date and show the result and then hope for some additional steps to try.

          Thanks for replying,

          Ken

          Comment


          • #6
            Ken, Color prints from the 70's - they've given all of us headaches!

            Like Stephen said, this is going to be a labor of love. One thing I would caution you about is trying to enlarge the image much. There doesn't appear to be much detail in the faces and enlarging the photo from it's original size will only exacerbate the lack of detail. You can try it, but from my experience, it's a much more difficult restoration because at the larger size you can see all of the imperfections.

            As far as how to go about restoring this one. If it were me, I'd turn the image to B&W, restore that as best I could, then colorize it. There are some photos that I've done this way where the client couldn't tell I colorized it after the fact. (And then there are those that no matter what I tried, it still looked colorized.)

            With this particular photo, it appears that the red channel has the least amount of damage. So, I would make the photo B&W, but use only the red channel - throwing out the green and blue channels. You can do this with the channel mixer or just delete the green and blue channels in the channels palette.

            Then do a levels (and maybe curves) adjustment to get better contrast of the B&W. You might want to try removing some of the noise. I've had good luck with Neat Image, but there are others out there as well. It looks like there's some damage that you'll need to address with cloning/healing brush as well.

            Once you've got the B&W where you want it, you can colorize it. I've seen some instances where you can take a copy of the original on the top layer and set it to colorize. In this case though, the colors seem too out of whack for that to work well. You might want to try it first just in case though. Otherwise, it will be a detailed process of coloring over everything in the photo. I always use a separate layer for each color that I paint on. This allows me to adjust the opacity and add a hue/saturation adjustment layer if needed for fine tuning.

            Hope this helps,
            Jeanie

            Comment


            • #7
              Thanks Jeanie. I have just about concluded what you suggested in your message.

              Also, about Neat Image. I have downloaded it and used it on this photo and it does improve things somewhat.

              The client (my spouse ) is pleased with what I have accomplished so far (relative to the original), so I am likely to have a satisfied "customer". Other than that, photos like these are "sinkholes" of time and labors of love. I wondered why I have not seen more like these in the challenges area---probably would get few submissions.

              Thanks for the response,

              Ken

              Comment


              • #8
                Ken,
                Though you had not asked for restoration of this photo, I tried it because it was very challenging. I'll post it if it is OK to do so.
                Svsg

                Comment

                Related Topics

                Collapse

                • Bristolpaul1
                  Challenging faded photo
                  by Bristolpaul1
                  Hi All,
                  I have an old faded photo taken in Florida many years ago,when my son was shorter than me,i thought repairing faded photos was suppose to be one of the easier things to do in photo restoration,but i am getting nowhere with this no matter what i try,i have tried a levels adjustment,resetting...
                  02-11-2015, 01:07 PM
                • Dave810
                  Color or not
                  by Dave810
                  I am going to try and restore this old pic of my wife's family. (the little girl holding the doll). I have a couple of ?'s. This is a color photo. You can see a little of the color here and there. I am wondering if trying to restore the color will be worth the effort. I have looked at the channels...
                  12-27-2010, 10:34 AM
                • Blues_X
                  is this one beyond hope?
                  by Blues_X
                  One of my co-workers asked me if I could take a look at an image she had and see if I could do anything to clear it up.
                  I've attached a JPEG version of the original scan.

                  It's a scan of a photo of a tintype image (not the best source material).

                  I worked on it a...
                  05-09-2003, 01:34 PM
                • nvslater
                  Need advice on restored/colorized photo
                  by nvslater
                  I have an old picture, that I am enclosing, it is from the 1840's. The wife's relative, so the pressure is on.This message will have the orginal, the next will have my restoration. I cut everthing, then color them separely. Herein is my problem, because it takes alot of time doing the pictures this...
                  10-13-2003, 10:13 PM
                • ♥Charlotte♥
                  Recover SEVERELY damaged and PRECIOUS photo?!
                  by ♥Charlotte♥
                  Hi All,

                  To view my previous thread on this, see 'Important image is corrupted - help!'
                  Didn't get many replies and some things have changed since then so this is basically to sum up all the additional details in one thread without keep adding replies to my old thread.
                  ...
                  07-22-2012, 05:10 AM
                Working...
                X