Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hue

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hue

    Hi,

    I use a Canon 400D, with sRGB setting. I get the image as I want it in the camera, and it looks the same when I preview it on my laptop, but as soon as I open it in RAW (in CS4 - also set to sRGB 8 bit), or select 'develop' in Lightroom, the image changes hue and washes out. It's especially bad with red hues, which turn orangey-green, and with light brown skin which end up looking unnatural and orange. It makes me wary of working with models with that lovely skin colour as it is so hideously altered in RAW. I spend so much time trying to get the colours back to what they were in real life but to no avail. I don't have this problem when shooting in JPEG, but that's not something I want to do as it will sacrifice image quality.

    When I asked this question over on the Adobe forums I was told that:

    No one can help you except to change your expectations.
    Canon takes the RAW data and creates an image.
    Adobe takes the RAW data and creates an image.
    Adobe isn't Canon, so the two RAW conversions won't be the same. Neither one is an "original" that you can "get back to" from the other.
    You're wasting your time getting something to look right in camera and then trying to duplicate that. Spend your time getting it right in ACR, instead.


    I find it hard to understand why I'm having such difficulty if this is normal. Is there nothing at all I can do to get more faithful colours without spending hours as I have been getting nowhere even close?

    Attached is an example:
    left: Image in camera, in windows preview and Lightroom preview on laptop. Right: Image when opened in RAW or after selecting 'Develop' in Lightroom.
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Re: Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hu

    Hi,

    Adobe does not recognize many of the Canon settings that Canon uses to generate jpeg images. This is why the images are different. Adjust one of your RAW images in ACR and then save the settings in ACR. You can then apply those settings on additional images.

    Using CS4 in 8 bit mode is not taking full advantage of it. You are seriously decreasing how much you can adjust an image.

    Alan

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hu

      Ysbyrd, please see the attached screenshot and check your Camera RAW settings. Here is what may be going on:
      Your camera has settings which you have entered or which are default Canon settings. These are primarily for Sharpness, Saturation, White Balance, Color Space. These instruct your camera on how to process / adjust the raw image data that comes off the sensor when saving the image in jpg or tiff. When you open the image in Camera RAW, the Camera RAW module by default takes the RAW data and does not apply those camera settings but instead applies Camera RAW defaults. If you want the preview to appear the same as what the camera would process if you saved the image as a jpg or tiff, then go up to the little context triangle, as in the screenshot, and change the preview from Camera Raw Defaults to Image Settings. This should look pretty close or bang on.
      Also a couple of things to remember. Make sure you properly set the color space, bit depth, and resolution seen by the arrow at the bottom center of the preview window. Also be sure that your working space in PS is set to the same color space OR (and I recommend you do this anyway), be sure to check the 3 profile preserve /mismatch warning boxes in PS Edit>Color Settings. That way if Camera Raw color setting gets changed, you will get a warning when you import the image into PS. Color space mismatches can significantly shift color and saturation.
      Regards, Murray
      Attached Files
      Last edited by mistermonday; 04-06-2011, 09:49 PM. Reason: typos

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hu

        I fixed it! It was such a simple thing - I just went to the 'camera calibration' tab and the dropdown was set to ACR 4.4 - I changed it to camera portrait which is what I ugenerally use and it was bang on. No fuss. Yay!

        Thanks for the advice, I'm not very technical and it takes me a while to figure out the simple things. *Doh*
        Attached Files

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Please help - RAW desaturating and altering hu

          I find it hard to understand why I'm having such difficulty if this is normal.
          When you shoot a JPEG, the camera takes the raw data and converts it using its own proprietary methods. When you shoot raw, a small JPEG, processed the same way is embedded into the raw so you can see it quickly. But all other raw processors, Adobe and all others have their own proprietary methods of converting from raw to JPEG for a preview. So they don’t necessary match and sometimes mismatch greatly.

          When you open a raw in ACR or LR, initially you see the camera generated JPEG, but then those (and other) products replace it by building their own preview JPEG. That’s why they look different. You can mess around with the various sliders to get a closer match (DNG camera profiles accessible in Calibration help too), then set this as the new ACR (or LR) default. All subsequent images will be processed initially with those settings. You can of course alter them now to taste.

          Note: setting the camera to sRGB has no role at all on the raw data. That only affects the JPEG.

          Comment

          Related Topics

          Collapse

          • fotogen
            Yellow Tint in Camera RAW?
            by fotogen
            I have been using Camera RAW for about a year now and I do like the interface. I do very little to the images in the tool except getting the color balance correct using a gray card.
            In my last shoot, I noticed that in Photoshop bridge, the images look fine in terms of color, but soon as I open...
            05-16-2010, 08:39 PM
          • mantra
            is there a way to downgrade camera raw?
            by mantra
            Hi

            is there a way to downgrade camera raw?

            i update cc camera raw to 9.1 , when i move the sliders (for example exposure) i got an excessive consumption , my cpu rires to 80% or 100%
            just move the exposure sliders faster and check your cpu , i use process hacker...
            06-17-2015, 10:37 AM
          • brsaicnaztrkou
            How come this photograph turns into this??
            by brsaicnaztrkou
            Hi everyone,

            I've been trying to figure out what auto processes are done to correct the image below. I am shooting raw and the files have been saved in both .jpeg and .dng format. I've spent like more than a month now trying to get the same result with the .dng to make it look like the...
            04-17-2016, 10:03 AM
          • helicopter
            RAW conversion - Canon 10D - green skin
            by helicopter
            Hello,

            If I try to open CRW files photographed using a Canon EOS 10D in Adobe Camera Raw or Capture One the skin tone in the shadows appear greenish. And currently I don't know how to achieve a pleasing skin tone without tweaking it in Photoshop. Because by comparison the JPEG using the...
            03-05-2007, 03:56 AM
          • rayi23
            Using Raw formats
            by rayi23
            Hello. I am a novice to Digital Photography and recently purchased a Nikon D3100. I do have a knowledge of Photoshop and currently using CS5 & CS4. I am trying to get the hang of using RAW format. I have been reading about it but I keep getting confused. So far it makes sense to me to use RAW but...
            04-29-2011, 08:30 AM
          Working...
          X