No announcement yet.

Comments, critique or feedback please!

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Comments, critique or feedback please!

    Thanks for taking a look at my Goldfish Project. I actually bought the goldfish and took about 100 shots of them to pic from, then put it together. Hope you guys like it!
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

    Like the floating in air fish result Oscar.


    • #3
      Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

      Thanks! I was going to go for the water look but found it way too difficult.


      • #4
        Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

        I like!

        Maybe a "thought bubble" from the black fish, saying something funny like "What, are my eyes bulging again?".


        • #5
          Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

          This seems like such a good piece of editorial art/commentary. More so because of the absence of "water". The water is not the focus, the fish are. Good. Did you alter the perspective of their positions or did you scout thru the 100 shots to find the right positions?


          • #6
            Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

            I actually scouted through the photos to get the positions, no altering (of the positions) at all. I still have more to look through so I might have another (hopefully cleaner) version of this.


            • #7
              Re: Comments, critique or feedback please!

              @Shizam - Lol. That would be a cool video.


              Related Topics


              • The_Leena
                Two pictures -need feedback and critique
                by The_Leena
                after a really long break I post-processed two pictures. What is more, I did that without my tablet because it's broken. I used my mouse instead. I am sure they are imperfect and that is why I need a critical eye to asses them and give me feedback what can be improved. I'd appreciate...
                04-17-2011, 07:18 AM
              • jeffroberto
                Critique Away
                by jeffroberto
                Just looking for some feedback if anyone has the time.
                04-26-2007, 10:10 PM
              • abh
                Critique please
                by abh
                hello Everyone,

                I am submitting this image for critique, would really like to hear what you have to say about it.

                methods used:
                1. blemish removal : heal/clone
                2. Skin work: D&B
                3. color shift: curves, hue/sat

                Credits :
                07-26-2010, 01:07 AM
              • StoryInPictures
                First image for critique...
                by StoryInPictures
                I'm new to the forum and figured I would jump in with both feet .

                I'm more of a photographer than a retoucher, but would appreciate your critical feedback. Please feel free to give blunt feedback on anything about the photography, lighting, retouching, short, anything...
                01-03-2018, 08:19 PM
              • Eskal-8
                Please critique..
                by Eskal-8
                Hi - I am trying to develop my skills and so at the moment just using random pics I find in Google Images - so feedback on this latest one will be really appreciated. Thanks!!...
                10-15-2010, 09:28 AM