No announcement yet.

How do I mask something like this?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • How do I mask something like this?

    As an example I will use a random shot got lying around.


    I need masks for:

    1. The camel
    2. The cart
    3. The guy sitting in the cart

    I am very very new to this so please bear with my newbie knowledge.

    So anyway, I can mask out the sky just fine using the blue channel and some level adjustment. But when it comes to masking out the camel, the cart and the guy, I am not able to do it with the channels. Maybe it has something to do with the contrast?

    PS: I have no problems masking out objects with a single colored background or something like the sky for example. But when the objects have a mixed background or a busy background, I am clueless.

    How would you go about masking these three items?

    Also, if it's the pen tool, refine edge or anything it would really be great to go through a tutorial of some sort too

    Thanks in advance.

  • #2
    Re: How do I mask something like this?

    Masking isn't that hard. It takes practice. Try not to zoom in too far. Usually 200% is fine for tight masking. Sometimes 100% is good. You lose too much perspective when you go in too tight.

    I would handle most things using either the pen tool or some careful paintbrush work. If you do anything with the paintbrush, make sure you treat that as tracing an outline, not filling in a solid shape. With the paintbrush tool, you can either use a layer mask with mask visibility toggled on or quick mask followed by some layer mask option.

    Tricks like increasing contrast in a particular manner or using refine edge may or may not work from image to image. If they leave many partially masked interior parts, then they aren't useful. If you have to blur a mask or anything like that, it will typically be something like either refine edge or gaussian blur with a 1 pixel width.

    In some cases like the interior parts of the tree, it may not be possible to create a clean perfect mask. It's okay. You mask out as much of it as you can cleanly separate, then deal with the rest later via color correction or other methods.

    It's important to realize here that this task doesn't require impeccable judgement or talent. It takes practice.


    • #3
      Re: How do I mask something like this?

      In addition to what Klev said, good masking takes time, especially if the object has a lot of detail. I use a brush for straight edges, and the pen tool for curves and round objects.

      It can help if you know what the new background will be. You can fade an edge that will not need to be so precise if the new background is similar to the original (helps avoid colored fringe).


      • #4
        Re: How do I mask something like this?

        IMO, the best thing you can do for yourself is gat a copy of Masking and Compositing by Katrin Eismann and go through the exercises.

        This image is relatively easy, except that the horizon is tilted, it looks over-sharpened to me (crunchy and some sharpening halos) and it isn't full resolution.

        Always work on the highest resolution you have so that the margins are as well defined as possible.


        • #5
          Re: How do I mask something like this?

          As you are looking for a masking tutorial, so you can see this https://www.clippingpathspecialist.c...air-photoshop/ .


          • #6
            Re: How do I mask something like this?

            Learn the pen tool. It'll be your best friend. You don't need to buy software or pluggins. Go on Youtube and search for Photoshop Pen Tool. (Start with Phlearn) There are a tons of videos to instruct you. There is no "quick" mask for intricate masking.


            Related Topics


            • skoobey
              Checking precision of your mask? How???
              by skoobey
              Okay, so ,we all know what masks are for etc... but...

              I was wondering what techniques do you use(or have heard of) that help check whether the mask is precise enough.

              For example, if you use the pen tool to select an arm, and then apply a curve to that selection, you don't...
              08-13-2013, 12:17 PM
            • booboo
              Cut out the person
              by booboo
              Hi everybody,

              I have a problem with cutting out the person from photos. I always do: Filter - Extract and then I mark the edges with the 'smart highligting'. Even after using 'edge touchup tool' and 'cleanup tool' I am not satisfied with my job.

              I'll show you my cutout...
              07-31-2008, 08:54 AM
            • Gee
              PROPER masking.
              by Gee
              hello, few questions here.
              hope you'll drop few tips!

              i'm really interested about doing proper/sharp masks.

              sometimes i select what i want to via the color range that i copy into a mask (& brushing in blacks where i want to)
              i like this cuz it gives...
              08-05-2009, 12:22 PM
            • jsm2
              How to simulate the 'Masking' slider?
              by jsm2
              Is it possible to simulate the 'Masking' slider form CameraRaw in Photoshop?
              'Find Edges' is the first obvious choice, but how to get that control in getting rid of that small detail, as 'Masking' does?
              09-07-2009, 11:35 PM
            • Lynda99
              Quickest way to mask
              by Lynda99
              I've been using the magic wand to select for applying a drop shadow. It works fine except when the selection has colors similar to the background. Checking 'contiguous' doesn't help.

              Everything else seems sooo time consuming. Is there anything else that is fast?

              08-14-2007, 01:25 PM