No announcement yet.

Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

    Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

    Does anyone here see a different between the two?

    When a photo is damaged, is there two different classes of repair and savior for the photo?

    For instance.....

    If you're repairing cracks and holes in a photo to make it look like it would have originally, we know that's a restoration.

    But, if you're recreating the photo based on what it looked like, but not repairing the source data, but instead creating your own perception of what it may have looked like, is that more of a re-interpretation than a restoration?

    There are a lot of very skilled restoration artists here, and I'm pretty amazing at what people can do sometimes, but if the results of the work look nothing like the original may have, except in context only, is it a restoration, or is it a re-interpretation?

    I'm just curious, what people think of the difference between a restoration and an artistic rendition of a restoration, and I thought it would be an interesting topic!

  • #2
    Re: Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

    The context and the client's choice are the 2 factors which will guide you. Of course this apply for the extreme damaged pics which had lost any hope to restore some of the original areas. I'm dealing every day with very damaged images because this is my speciality and people send to me real bad files. The first and more important step is consult the owner and ask for his/her preferences. Mainly the worst part of the job is the background and clothes restoration. Face must be restored as original but if you deal with a very charged background, with many details and very bad state you'll need too much time, maybe days to redo this. I'm rejecting this kind of jobs unless we could agree about the background replacement. It's not the best but I can't stay 2 days to resore background's people, clothes, trees and flowers, buildings, which demand x4 than the main person (face, body, clothes) retouch. The plugings are useless over the small details restore too, you have to use some other tool and restore manually every small detail. Sometimes I cut some parts of the image if the client agrees, specially when the pic lost very difficult parts to restore as hands and has no chance to do a decent restore. I don't like tu copy and paste other's pictures parts over the current work. So, the ideal situation is to work and restore the image as-is but sometimes you'll must take another way, maybe. However, no change should be done without the client's approval.


    • #3
      Re: Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

      Yes, I don't do a lot of restorations, but occasionally, I get ones where pieces of the photo just can't be repaired and need to be replaced.

      It's not often I find people who care though-- generally, they say, "If I can see the face (or the person), the rest doesn't matter."


      • #4
        Re: Restoration vs Re-Interpretation

        Yes, that's right. Face is capturing the 90% of the cilent's choice. Try to improve the eyes restoration, as we talked before. The eyes are the key, they express the subect's personality. Have pacience and also observe some eyes drawings, its parts and always try to imagine in the current work every anatomic detail superposed over the layer/background. You must paint first with your view, your imagination and the hand will follow you easely.


        Related Topics


        • Chain
          Restoration - heavily damaged
          by Chain
          I found this restoration quite challenging, so I thought maybe some people here might find it interesting to practise on as well. It was done for some random guy over at reddit.

          (yes, he only gave us a jpeg to work with)

          My final...
          07-12-2011, 04:37 AM
        • Leon William
          7 steps for photo restoration using Photoshop
          by Leon William
          If you are planning to carry out restoration of old damaged photos without relying on a professional, this article is for you.

          Read here to find out 7 simple steps for that.
          08-10-2017, 03:36 AM
        • Doug Nelson
          Photo Restoration Jobs: Increasing or Decreasing?
          by Doug Nelson
          The photo restoration business landscape has changed a lot since we went online back in 2001. Possibly the biggest change has been...well, us

          But there's also lots more books and publicity, but also outsourcing, but also more markets, but also more do-it-yourself, but also more...
          11-26-2007, 12:37 PM
        • s.keenum
          Restoration Help
          by s.keenum
          I am new to this site and to photo restoration in general. I have inherited some old B&W family photos that I scanned (in color mode) and am trying to restore. Most of these photos have fading/some tint from age. My questions are:
          What do you correct first? Remove the color cast? Fix scratches,...
          12-08-2006, 02:38 PM
        • Pete Donegan
          More Authentic Photo Restoration
          by Pete Donegan
          Hi everybody! It's ages since I posted but I've just started on a job of restoration and I thought I would like to run some ideas past the experts on Retouch PRO to see what you think. I've been doing photo restoration for quite a few years now, but something has got me thinking. We use tools like the...
          11-24-2014, 05:02 PM