Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Resto questions

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Resto questions

    Hi,

    I've attached a photo of my late father-in-law (viewers far left). He was a Dispatch Rider in the British Army during WW II. This copy has not been changed in any manner. I usually do a levels/curves approach first, then go on to repair. However, there appears to be a lot of grain/noise/grunge which I initially tried to remove with the PS dirt and scratches filter, then with Topaz Denoise. Those efforts would remove the noise, but the detail suffered badly. As far as the detail (particularly eyes) I was unable to recover very much with levels or curves. The efforts to remove noise certainly didn't help. Fortunately the photo is free of major rips and tears, but suffers badly from small scratches. Those efforts are NOT reflected in the attached photo!

    So my questions:

    What would be your thoughts on the best way to clean up the photo and restore detail?? Should I go back to the tried and true method of repair tools (clone stamp/healing brush) or renew efforts with D&S filter and/or Topaz Denoise (I haven't tried Topaz AI Denoise yet)? Is there enough facial detail to actually recovery or should I be satisfied with what I have?

    I would really like to do a decent job on this restoration and present to his great- grand-sons! I thank everyone for their thoughts and recommendations.

    bexar

    SE Queensland, Australia

    George-WWII_WEB.jpg

  • #2
    You could try making a duplicate layer, and on the first layer run whichever filter you think does the best job regardless of detail. On the top layer use a larger brush size than you'd use for spotting and paint out the dusty areas on the layer mask, letting the lower level show through.

    But it actually doesn't look that bad to me. If the above doesn't help, just use the old school method. Zoom into the top left, put on some chill music, and go to town with the spot heal brush. When done, hit page down and do the next tiny area. You'd be amazed at how fast it can go. It can even be pleasant if you get into the zone.
    Learn by teaching
    Take responsibility for learning

    Comment


    • #3
      Doug,

      Thank you for the helpful reply. I'll sure try the filtering and masking trick! In looking at the photo, I can not see eye pupils or a lot of detail in the nearest motorcycle engine. Is that level of missing detail recoverable? If so, what would be your approach! Again, thank you for the help!!

      bexar

      Comment


      • #4
        The hardest problem in restoration is that if data is gone in the original, it is gone. If that detail is absolutely necessary, all you can do is borrow parts of other photos or literally paint it in. But I've found it's not usually necessary. People generally understand that you're not making it look like it was taken recently. That's another reason why I never got too perfectionist on restorations, it can look weird if some parts are perfect but other parts are still obviously from an old photo.
        Learn by teaching
        Take responsibility for learning

        Comment

        Related Topics

        Collapse

        • TommyO
          Topaz DeNoise 4.0 - Pretty Slick
          by TommyO
          All,
          Like most of us, I rely on third party noise removal software. I decided to download the latest 30-day trial version of Topaz' DeNoise, version 4. I did not like the results in version 3. However, I'm finding it to be pretty darn good at its defaults. In fact, I'm liking it better than...
          05-17-2010, 10:40 PM
        • jack zucker
          Disappointed in Topaz Adjust
          by jack zucker
          Anyone else think that it adds too much grain/noise to the photos?
          12-03-2011, 09:19 PM
        • elliotrobinson
          Is this photo restorable?
          by elliotrobinson
          Hi everyone,

          This is a photo taken behind the scenes on the set of the show 'Little House on the Prairie'. I'd love to restore this photo as it is special and very rare. I only have about 2 years of experience restoring photos (as a hobby) on Adobe Photoshop, but I have never worked on...
          05-23-2015, 01:04 PM
        • tayoo123
          Topaz Denoise 3.0 I need Help
          by tayoo123
          I followed tutorial on denoise 3.0, tried on badly severe underexposed picture, I still get the same result , I saw the denoise used to fix badly severe under exposed picture, he used adobe cs 4, which I have, I will upload image . I followed the instructions on the tutorial, I still get the same image...
          03-03-2010, 08:12 PM
        • sponge03
          Whats Topaz DeNoise like?
          by sponge03
          I'm thinking of buying Topaz DeNoise, anyone had experience using it?

          Whats it like, worth the price?
          05-28-2009, 05:13 PM
        Working...
        X