Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What would you do

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • What would you do

    I'm working on this old wedding picture for a friend and I wonder what others would do in this situation.

    In the attached image, you can see some damage to the chair leg. That damage is on the chair itself and not on the picture. Also the canvas floor cloth the coupleis sitting/standing on is rumpled and the bride's silk stockings are wrinkled around her ankles.

    I could "fix" all these things, but should I?

    I prefer to keep the image as much original as possible because I think the damage on the chair leg and the rumpled floor cloth tell part of the story. Also, anyone whose ever seen those old stockings knows how impossible it was to keep them straight.

    What would you do??

    Margaret
    Attached Files

  • #2
    Margaret,

    I'd talk to my friend and show him/her what is possible, and then ask what they would prefer -- perhap they'll want one of each.

    Comment


    • #3
      If the photo was taken yesterday you'd probably have little hesitation about fixing the chairleg or the stocking. I see no reason to let the age of the image stop you. But ultimately, I'd ask your friend.

      I know this one is for a friend, but if this was for a client I'd also have to consider the time involved and the estimated cost given.
      Learn by teaching
      Take responsibility for learning

      Comment


      • #4
        I always ask first.

        Comment


        • #5
          Hmmmm, I think I worded that wrong. I will ask my friend but I wanted to know what your own thoughts are on "changing history" by altering elements of the photo.

          When I look at old photos, I'm as interested in the weathered barn door that Grandpa is standing in front of, the brown tobacco stains on his fingers, the fly-away hair on Grandma's head and the way Uncle Fred's pants always hung crooked even with suspendors.

          I worked on a candid photo of my son's friends taken at their wedding. The couple liked the candid shot better than the studio ones and wanted me to turn it into a "studio" look. The background etc. was no problem, but the bride's face looked awful - all wrinkled, she looked 50 instead of 25 (I have not met the bride in person) I smoothed out the wrinkles and made her look radiant.

          When my son saw the finished product, he was shocked!! Apparently, those wrinkles were natural and removing them would insult her. Fortunately, I had saved a copy just before I started on the wrinkles.

          I could take the one photo that exists of Aunt Mary and Uncle Pete and pose them closer together (they are several feet apart and she is leaning away from him) and I could remove the old stove and pile of wood from behind them, but in life, they NEVER got closer than arms length (at least in public ) and that old stove and wood pile says a lot about the simple way they lived - I think it would be wrong to change that.

          Margaret

          Comment


          • #6
            I will do whatever the customer wants. The idea of "changing history" doesn't even enter my mind. It's not like I'm working for Time magazine or anything.....that would be a whole different story.

            Comment


            • #7
              Margaret,

              If you were my client -- I wouldn't change the wrinkles in the stockings, the chair leg damage, etc.

              When I look at the old photos of my ancestors, I am interested in those "true" details surrounding them -- although in most cases, they're sitting in a photographer's set. Personally, however, I also want to have a better image of them. I tend to fix things in my own family's photos -- then I have the original to enjoy as well as an "improved" version.

              If there is true history involved -- family or regional or even further, then saving the details of the original as they were is vital. But I have no argument against enhancing a copy also.

              Comment


              • #8
                Margaret,

                I think that you should always ask the Client first what they would like. Having said that, I find that sometimes they are not really sure, so you can tell or show them what is/may be possible, and even recommend an approach if they are not comfortable doing so.

                I do lean towards preserving as much of old photos as possible, because I think it adds to the character of the photo, but of course there are circumstances (like severity of damage) that have to be weighed.

                Alan

                Comment


                • #9
                  I agree with everybody here in that its up to customer. I also agree with you in that when I do a Restoration I only fix what has been damaged by time. Well most of the time. In this example I made many changes because it was taken by a bad photographer and the customer agreed with me wedding

                  When in doubt ask the client.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Very nice job, Noko. Much needed improvement.

                    The key word in all this is "ask".

                    I've noticed on the challanges, that many people take the liberty of changing backgrounds, colors, etc., even though the directions specifically say, "do not change anything". Although these are not for actual customers, it's a very important part of the restoration process. I don't recall if any books on restoration cover this topic.

                    Talk about changing history......
                    I had a female customer ask me to do something similar. Her wedding photos had been taken in the 70's, and in a very unattractive background. She wanted it to look as if they were taken in a studio, with a studio background. I did the enhancements, and she was thrilled. About a year later, I ran in to her at a picnic. She told me, jokingly, that her and her husband had since split up, and that perhaps having the pictures changed had been an omen.

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Thanks Vikki

                      Comment

                      Related Topics

                      Collapse

                      • AlexFournelle
                        Call for help : about that finishing touch...
                        by AlexFournelle
                        Hello everyone,

                        First time posting here, although I lurked (sporadically) for years. Sorry, in advance, for my poor english, I promise I do as best as I can.

                        I've been tasked by my loving father with repairing a picture of my great grandfather. My grandmother (she's a great-great-grandmother...
                        10-13-2009, 09:36 PM
                      • Mark Adams
                        Two problems
                        by Mark Adams
                        Attached is a picture of my former spouse. She passed away two years ago but when she was in her early twenties, she had this portrait taken. We all like this picture, but the only surviving copy we have is a 5 X 7 that got wet and until yesterday was stuck to a piece of glass in a picture frame....
                        05-17-2005, 07:09 PM
                      • Craig Walters
                        A very old photograph
                        by Craig Walters
                        i wasnt sure where to post this, but this forum seemed the most appropriate. if not, could a moderator please move it to where it would be.

                        this is, what i think, a photo of a photo. the original is apparently lost, but someone made a re-photo before the original was destroyed or lost...i...
                        06-24-2005, 09:12 PM
                      • Billfields
                        Worth the Effort?
                        by Billfields
                        I think I may have posted this picture before, maybe a year or so ago. It is of my great grandfather and his children taken about 100 years ago and as you can see, it has been well handled and shared over the last century. I would like to, if not restore, at least improve it. I am defiantly a novice...
                        07-09-2005, 12:12 PM
                      • Jakaleena
                        How Much Artistic License?
                        by Jakaleena
                        Ok, ethics question here...

                        The scenario is that you're doing a restoration job for a client. How much artistic license do you take? And what reasons do you have for drawing the line at that particular place? What is fair game for changing, and what do you consider "sacred"?...
                        05-05-2002, 12:12 PM
                      Working...
                      X