No announcement yet.

Crop with Perspective acting strange

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Crop with Perspective acting strange

    In an upcoming tutorial (look for The X-ray Brush when the Tutorial Publishing System is functional again) I retouched a photo of a church. As a final touch I wanted to correct perspective and used the Crop tool. It worked flawlessly -- I thought. When I compared the images side by side, it turned out the Crop had metamorphosed Legolas into Gimli!

    Instead of a tall, stately church I got a squat building of sorts. The height in pixels has been retained, but the ratios between the various levels is weird. It looks like a "funny mirror" in a tivoli.

    I have attached an image of a ruler. It seems to me that the change in height ratio follows an unnatural curve. Real life is not as dramatic as this. This looks like an 18mm Wide.

    Why? Is there a better way?

  • #2
    Now where is the image? Argh! I forgot to click Upload.
    Attached Files


    • #3
      Ok, here's one answer, but it immediately produces two new questions.

      If I don't do the perspective change in one fell swoop, but instead in small increments, then height ratio is maintained. Legolas remains Legolas, only with broader shoulders and ... uh ... a swollen head

      Q1: Why?
      Q2: Will this lead to massive pixel death? My gut feeling is that performing many transformations on a picture will result in loss of detail.


      • #4

        I don't have the answers for you. The following is probably *not* your problem, but it's a possibility. When the image looks wierd to you, are you viewing it at 100%? I've seen what appears to be some very strange transformations when viewing at something other than 100%! I have no idea why this is, but if I make a print, it doesn't show up distorted, even though it does on the monitor. Also, if I change the view to 100%, it looks much different (not distorted). This is something that I've only noticed a couple of times, but it came to mind when I read your post.

        Now if someone will give the *real* answer, I'd be interested too.



        • #5
          Rexx, I've tried to understand the issue but I may not be completely "getting it"... to correct perspective, I don't use the crop tool often, I use edit/transform/perspective. That way I can immediately see the results of my adjustments. If you do use the perspective feature of the crop tool, it will maintain the original height -- same as with the edit/transform/perspective feature. It surprises me that you can get the result you want by doing the changes in smaller increments....

          One way to do it is to enlarge the height of the canvas prior to doing the correction. Then do edit/transform/perspective to get the vertical walls you are looking for, then increase the height to get the right aspect ratio by edit/transform/distort.

          I've looked at the other options for the tools and can't see a way to maintain original aspect ratio "automatically."

          sorry I couldn't be more help,


          • #6
            Here's your distorted rule corrected back to "normal" twice, once just using perspective crop on the original image, once using it on the original image with the canvas resized first by 200%
            Attached Files
            Learn by teaching
            Take responsibility for learning


            Related Topics


            • Frank Lopes
              The Art of Cropping
              by Frank Lopes
              First of all a disclaimer:

              I'm horrible at cropping. Most of the time, the notion of volumes and spaces, balance or rule of thirds, is beyond me.

              I have a hard time visualizing by looking at a photo, how I could improve the image just by appropriately cropping it.
              01-12-2008, 09:43 AM
            • jclguru
              I hate cropping...ugh!
              by jclguru
              I have an image that according to ps is 14x9 inches. I'd like an 8x10.
              No matter what I try, nothing works.

              I've tried cropping using the 8x10 as my values. Which, width wise,
              isn't enough. If I rotate my image (making it a 9x14) and change the
              crop values to 10x8,...
              03-21-2005, 09:14 PM
            • junipaire
              Help with cropper tool in photoshop
              by junipaire
              I think I'm going slightly insane here , I have a picture 24 inch by 24 inch and open it up in photoshop, I want to crop it to A4 size so 8.267inch by 11.693inch so I put in the measurements in the boxes to get a crop shape A4 size but weirdly the shape comes out nearly covering the 24 inch by 24 inch...
              09-12-2005, 08:02 AM
            • charlotte
              Zooming ,cropping and angling a photo
              by charlotte
              I am curious how does one do what the retoucher calls Zoom and crop -is this being done in Photoshop?

              also how does he or she angle the photo - I am trying to learn different techniques and this one I can't...
              05-12-2004, 12:57 PM
            • amtb
              Unusual perspective problem
              by amtb
              This is a problem I have not met before and so far I haven't found an answer.

              The shot was taken on the down escalator of a London department store. I wasn't too careful with it and thought it would not be very difficult to correct the perspective so that it looked as if it had been...
              01-07-2005, 02:15 PM