Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Color Wheel vs Color Spectrum

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Color Wheel vs Color Spectrum

    Hi Folks- I am a newbie to Retouchpro-(Not to Photoshop, however)

    There seem to be a few math (and maybe science) geeks out here so I figured I'd toss this out to you.

    The color spectrum seems to be a linear model with ever decreasing wavelengths as you climb up the spectrum.

    Red-Yellow-Green-Blue-Violet

    However, we can predictively add colors with a "wheel" model.
    It seems intuitive that Yellow and green would produce Blue-the average of the 2 wavelengths of energy.


    But.....how come mixing Red and Blue does not produce some average of those wavelengths? (a yellowish-green)

    Instead, it produces a Magenta (Violet-like?) color.

    It's as if our eyes and brains are wired to see a linear physical reality (the spectrum) as if it were joined at the ends so that it forms a circle.

    Does this seem strange to anyone else or should I just "let it go?"
    Cheers
    Bob

  • #2
    I understand where you're coming from, Bob. But I don't have an answer for you, so I'll just say "Welcome to RP".

    Ed

    Comment


    • #3
      The color wheel works because the human eye RGB cones aren't quite R,G, and B. Very roughly-speaking, the blue cones see from about violet to green (with a peak in the middle of blue.) The green cones see from about blue to red (with a peak in green). The red cone sees from green to red (with a peak in the yellow/orange range), but it also has a passband up at violet. This latter property is key because it means the red cone essentially completes the circle by sensing the shortest wavelength violets in addition to reds thus overlapping with the short-wavelength side of blue.

      So violet light stimulates both the red and blue cones and you interpret that as violet. For slightly longer (bluer) wavelengths, the red is no longer stimulated and you see blue. If you alternatively shine red + blue light, it also stimulates the red and blue cones and you see violet. This is why you (the human eye) can't tell the difference between true spectral violet and a mixture of red and blue. This is also why digital cameras will see true violet as blue. Ie they can tell the difference between pure violet and red/blue, but they can't tell the difference between pure violet and pure blue.

      I'm sure we've all taken photos of purple flowers or (more rarely) clothing only to have them turn out blue. This is because the flower was spectrally pure violet.

      Using your digicam, you can tell if something is pure violet rather than blue + red. If you saw the item as purple and it came out blue, then it was spectral violet. If the purple item came out looking purple, then you know it's really a mixture of red and blue. I've seen flowers ranging from absolutely pure violet to some combination of violet, blue, and red. In the latter case, the flower comes out looking about right.

      I assume camera manufacturers don't put a violet passband on the red color filter in digicams for reasons of manufacturing difficulty. It's possible that the highest-end DSLR's might incorporate this, but as far as I know, they don't.

      Bart

      Comment


      • #4
        ...did somebody here call a Geek?

        OK, so let's say it like an electron. Can be thought of as a wave or as a particle.
        Nah, just kidding....

        But, really, the answer is something like that. Have a look at this diagram.
        http://www.efg2.com/Lab/Graphics/Col...romaticity.htm

        The numbers around the outline are wavelengths. So you can see that it is both linear, and circular at the same time.

        The Red-to-Blue "workaround" can be seen as the straight line joining the two end points.



        Comment


        • #5
          Thanks Folks-Great explanation Bart!
          Now if only we were wired so that we could perceive the other 8 dimensions...nah..... too confusing...

          I wonder what evolutionary purpose this pass filter serves.. nature is fond of circles

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by byRo
            ...did somebody here call a Geek?

            OK, so let's say it like an electron. Can be thought of as a wave or as a particle.
            Nah, just kidding....



            Maybe it's a bunch of particles that form themselves into a wave pattern.

            Comment


            • #7
              a bunch of particles that form themselves into a wave pattern.......

              . . .
              . . . .
              . . .

              exactly!

              Comment


              • #8
                Groan!!!

                Originally posted by byRo
                a bunch of particles that form themselves into a wave pattern.......

                . . .
                . . . .
                . . .

                exactly!

                Uuuuugggh!

                Bart

                Comment


                • #9
                  You asked for that!

                  Comment

                  Related Topics

                  Collapse

                  • Art Cartmell
                    Separating Colour Components
                    by Art Cartmell
                    Hi Richard,

                    I have read the first 5 chapters of HPPE3 and am now going back to read them again and hopefully this time take in more than I did the first time. Right away I found a question regarding the separation of colour components on page 46. In step 5, you state that we can turn...
                    01-25-2006, 05:44 PM
                  • kathleen
                    Additive/Subtractive
                    by kathleen
                    Paulette,

                    zackly! I have had the same thought re the fact that, well, that's where the facts are. (Physics, I mean)

                    i have been especially befuddled by a lifetime of believing yellow and blue make green not being true anymore. I really don't understand why and have trouble...
                    08-18-2001, 03:15 PM
                  • tinamou
                    totally Yellow
                    by tinamou
                    Hi,

                    I wonder if anyone can point me in the right direction with this photograph I have of a friend. He is celbrating his 40th year of ordination this coming Sunday and I would love to be able to present him with a half decent picture but cant seem to get the yellow caste out of the pcture...
                    09-15-2006, 06:39 AM
                  • Bluewing
                    Red Photo
                    by Bluewing
                    Hello everyone here is one that I have been trying to work on tried replacing the red channel doesn't seem to work. Could use some advice.


                    Thanks

                    Blue...
                    07-20-2006, 02:44 PM
                  • paulette conlan
                    Using curves for color correction
                    by paulette conlan
                    I'm trying to follow along with a tutorial on color correcting images using curves. The RGB image they used as an example had a yellow cast so what they did was go to the blue channel in the curves dialog box and make adjustments there since blue is the complement to yellow.So far so good.Now I want...
                    09-05-2001, 02:55 PM
                  Working...
                  X