Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

    And I was trying to make "new group"- and nothing happened. I have reach the limit of Photoshop CS3... Should I ask Adobe to return money?

    as a attachment "challenge.zip" I put maximum down-sized original .psd file with all layers.
    Attached Files
    Last edited by stopa; 06-18-2008, 01:55 AM.

  • #2
    Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

    there is a limit to groups and nested layers, but i think the layer limit in cs3 depends on your memory...

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

      I was able to add more new groups and put lots of new layers into new groups. I'm not sure what I have exactly; the layers palette is very long. - 20 groups.
      1 gig memory.

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

        stopa, I thought this might interest you

        This is an excerpt from an interview in 2005 with Bert Monroy at "Where is Ben?":

        Q: On average, how many layers do your images contain and how large are the file sizes?

        Bert:
        The flattened file of the “Oakland” measures 20 x 15 inches at 480 ppi. That makes for a 197 meg file. I did say flattened. Due to the massive amount of layers that make up any of the individual parts of my image, I had to break it up into many files for each segment of the painting.

        There were six individual files where each element was produced. As an example, the marquee behind the name Oakland was a file on it’s own without the word Oakland. The working file with all the paths, layers, alpha channels and such weighed in at 1.5 gigs in size. There are a total of 226 layers. That is JUST for the marquee. I don’t know how many alpha channels there were because I
        don’t always save them after using.

        I would guess the total number of layers for the overall image would be well into the thousand range.

        Bert Monroy's page is <here>

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

          Thanx for your advances. But I post this message rather as a anecdote. I did this massive composition a year ago - and now is my time for retrospection.
          Believe me: I had a terrible headache, time was running fast, accounts managers was on the phone, and my old computer (with 2Gb) was breaking out in a sweat...
          Somebody ask: "how it is to act as a "pro"?". And my answer is: "those 222 layers was a one month of my life. And I questioning myself was it worth it? "
          Now I have a pleasant memory of this experience... and I change my computer for a faster one

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

            Yeah, and it may help to revise your working methods a little -thats one of the stupidest layer structures I've ever seen. Theres absolutely no need for all that. Piling multiple adjustment layers onto an image is extremely destructive and usually unnecessary. Dumping successive color fills onto the image is also generally a waste of time. If you really think you need all that ( and you are wrong by the way of you do), and you want simplify the layer structure simpler a little, try smart objects. The more experienced you get the more confident you become at simplifying things.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

              CAN U PLEASE PoST THAT IMAGE!!!!.... LOL..that thing better be worth millions.. and better be one hell of a retouch!...LOL

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                MarkZebra! You are right! It was crazy. All whole the assumption was wrong.

                I did this project with KBX (www.kbx.blog.pl) he was a photographer, and creationist of this image. (KBX is the most influenced artist I ever known) My task was to set up the montage, and merge it down...

                It was build with over 80 images (most of them are in the background).
                The composition for 12x3 outdoor has 5 character on the "old left site".
                On the "modern right site" we had heavy party grills, kites, umbellas, beer, and throng of people.
                The main idea was to make One-Good-Composition, and than just crop it for a whole variety of formats (according the media plan).
                As we go for it, it became more and more clear, that we have to move each object for a 1-5 centimeters, if we want to change our formats. (from 12x3 to 3x4)
                So we decide to make EACH object moveable - and belive me it works... but very, very slow... (my MBP was standing on a 4 bricks, in case of over-heating).

                In the middle of this commission, I discover the smart objects. And belive I didn't have time to implement it.
                It was the craziest thing I ever did... but I attain really heavy experience.
                Thanks KBX!

                http://www.retusz.info/2007rok/Kasztelan_2806.jpg
                Last edited by stopa; 06-17-2008, 11:36 PM.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                  This I can understand, I've had to build shots for clients wanting to use the one shot for various uses, different sized billboards, metrolites, A0 posters, A4 magazine ads, landscape and portrait. It's impossible to build something that can be flattened down and cropped for all of those uses, things need to be left layered so they can be moved around according the format.

                  Having said that, I do find that layers pallet quite ridiculous.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                    If you're working on something massively major, you should have iterations of the same file at various stages of the retouching process. I know a certain well known and highly regarded retouching studio in London that takes this approach.

                    When the dust spots and general cleaning of an image is done, then that particular PSD is appropriately named with a coding system that determines what has been done to it and then archived. They then start from the new flattened approved image. Then the colour work is done, name the PSD, file that PSD, work from a new approved flattened image and so on.

                    This way you can go back to various stages of the process and all the work is safe and manageable. More importantly all your hard work and effort isn't contained on one PSD. What would you do if that file became corrupt for some reason?

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                      Grate workflow Stive, thanks. (bdw, I did backup each day)
                      Also, I did retouch before composition, those 222layers was made to reach the photorealistic effect... I mean ambient light, shadows, specular, abberations, blurs, atmospheric, ect.

                      Now I know that content excess essence- but what the hell! We are learning on our mistakes!
                      Last edited by stopa; 06-17-2008, 11:48 PM.

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                        In response to you Steve, yes thats generally the best way to work, not great if you have one hard drive though. Another option is to have a server setup that creates the archives over a two week period - I've great hopes for the new Time Machine feature in Leopard, with a large enough spare drive, you could effectively do the whole thing without any manual effort.

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                          I use superDuper for backup. It is grate software. (SuperDuper automatic duplicate my RAID0 matrix to another physical disc 4-5 times per day)

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                            yeh, no. get more memory and come back later.

                            Also, alot of people, pro's alike, need lessons in workflow. I used layer-whore and feel super ambitious solely because I had many layers. Alot things I did turned out not to need so many layers to do.

                            and also, I NEVER FLATTEN, my entire workflow is based around nondestructive editing, I dont even need the "history" window because I never really edit anything. If I erase something, it was probably a layer mask.

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Re: The limit??? Over 210 layers- yes limits!

                              Synthetamine, it is better to think before you write.
                              Me "pro's alike" - send this file as a anecdote.
                              And tell me - how to put more memory than 2G to MBP from 2006y?

                              Comment

                              Related Topics

                              Collapse

                              • iceblue1980
                                Gazzilion layers - advise needed
                                by iceblue1980
                                Hello fellow retouchers!

                                I'm an intermidiate user of PhotoShop (CS3) and started out 2002. I still have alot to learn

                                I like to do glamour retouching and I work with amature photos that I edit greatly. I use layers for everything, every little edit. Like for instance...
                                03-04-2008, 08:12 AM
                              • AKMac
                                Locking Multiple Layers
                                by AKMac
                                Is there a way of locking multiple layers in PS5, other than doing so one-by-one? I don't want to lock all parameters, just pixels.
                                03-17-2012, 04:07 PM
                              • surfbug
                                Layers?
                                by surfbug
                                I am beginner, I have 10 layers How do I copy the layers and flat image although I still have the regular layers as well?
                                07-15-2015, 11:41 AM
                              • bobzilla
                                Copying All Layers from One PS File to Another
                                by bobzilla
                                If I have two Photoshop files with lots of layers and I want to copy one file with all it's layers into another file, how would I do that? Right now, I'm temporarily merging the layers, copying that layer, and bringing that onelayer into my other document? Is there another way?

                                I'm in...
                                08-15-2004, 05:58 PM
                              • jonk
                                Flatten vs Merge
                                by jonk
                                Hi All!

                                Can anyone answer what is the difference between Flattening an image vs Merging Visible? I really do not know what the difference between them are.

                                Thanks Again!
                                Jon
                                03-29-2005, 07:33 PM
                              Working...
                              X