No announcement yet.

Help With Scanner Selection

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Help With Scanner Selection

    Good morning, I'm doing research into what drum film scanner would be the best for me to buy at a good price.
    I have about 20+ years of negatives that I need to convert to digital. One heck of a job to do. I'm looking forward in working with you to find the best for my budget and to assist in making the conversion. Thanks in advance for your assistance. God Bless...

    B Miller

  • #2
    Re: Help With Scanner Selection

    Why do you need a drum scanner? Is a dedicated Negative Film & Slide scanner not adequate?
    Cheers, Murray


    • #3
      Re: Help With Scanner Selection

      I just finished scanning about 4000 slides. Took two years. Bought a dedicated slide scanner to do it - a good thing since my Lightroom lost a bunch, and I had to do them over. Not that this has anything to do with the job at (your) hand. Just for info, I used a Plustek and Silverfast 8 sw, scanned at 2400 ppi, which allowed a 5x7 print with minimal cropping. The Plustek hardware also does 35 mm negatives. It costs about $400.

      Which brings me to my question. Why DO you need a drum scanner?


      • #4
        Re: Help With Scanner Selection

        It would help if you could specify how much you're willing to spend and whether you opt for quality over speed or the other way round. There are scanners for certain purposes: preserving negatives (consumer grade), small prints/web (semi-pro) and the specialized ones for commercial use (purpose-built film scanners).

        Most of the scanners on the market are crap with negatives. DPI is not important, what really counts is optical density (also called DMax). That leaves you with a few options:

        Flatbed scanners with film holder: (order by price tag, ascending)
        Epson V700
        Epson V750
        Film scanners only:
        Nikon Coolscan 5000 ED (35mm negative/slide only)
        Nikon Coolscan 9000 ED (35, 6x6, 6x7, etc)
        Hasselblad Flextight series (35, 6x6, 6x7, etc)

        Either way you're looking at something around 700-800 USD for a flatbed and a few to twenty-something thousand (starting from around 3000$ for Coolscan 9000) for a specialized film scanner.


        Related Topics


        • Caravaggio
          recommendations on a new scanner
          by Caravaggio
          Hi, I'm doing some work on a documentary and am looking for recommendations on a professional scanner. I will be scanning archival photos and slides. I have an epson perfection v500 scanner. It seems to do a decent job scanning photos but gets pretty bad results scanning 35 millimeter slides. Can you...
          07-06-2015, 03:13 PM
        • KevinBE
          Film Scanner
          by KevinBE
          I don't know if anyone is interested but I bought a Minolta Speed Scan film scanner on ebay. I just couldn't pass it up because of the price. I know it's discontinued from production but it had a suggested retail of 1299.00 and it has had some good reviews. I think the last street price of this scanner...
          08-22-2003, 06:50 PM
        • Momadoodle
          Which scanner to buy?
          by Momadoodle
          I'm just starting a small business and have clients who want slides scanned. I have an HP that scans up to 3 slides, but has no dust removal software.

          I would like to spend around $500 and am looking at the CanoScan 9950F, which seems to have been discontinued. Another option I've seen...
          01-12-2007, 12:04 PM
        • Bruce Hayes
          To Buy A new Scanner
          by Bruce Hayes
          Im looking into buying a new flatbed scanner. I would like some input on some goodones. I don't need one that scans film I have a film scanner. Any help hould be nice

          08-22-2004, 01:19 PM
        • FrannyMae
          Nikon CoolScan V ED Film Scanner??
          by FrannyMae
          My brother is looking into a filmscanner, and has been looking at the Nikon CoolScan V ED. Anyone have any experience with this scanner they would be willing to share?

          Thanks for your input!
          10-13-2004, 10:34 PM