No announcement yet.

OVERALL which is better? Canon i9100 or Epson Stylus Pro 2200.

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • OVERALL which is better? Canon i9100 or Epson Stylus Pro 2200.

    I'm going to buy one of these two printers and really can't make up my mind. Most reviews I've read from people who bought them gave about 4.5 out of 5 stars for the 2200 and about 5 out of 5 stars for the i9100...of course stars don't really mean anything but their reviews gave some good points which kinda lead me to believe them.

    So let's talk about their pros and cons. There are so many pros in each of the 2 but also are about equal amount of cons in both.

    OK this is all the info I gathered so far:
    (when I say pros n cons I mean their differences FROM each other, not in general ; )

    i9100 pros:
    -costs about $200 less
    -a little better photographic printing quality due to the "The 2 pl droplet" - (2200 has 4 pl droplet )
    -installs fast and easy to operate
    -cleanable heads

    i9100 cons:
    -printed ink lasts ~25yrs
    -not enough paper choices for high quality prints (artists papers) - this is only what I've read, however if you go to Canon's website there are plenty papers to choose from, I just dont know if they're really good enough for their price.

    2200 pros:
    -a little better b&w printing because it's got 2 kinds of black inks.
    -printed ink lasts ~90yrs
    -many great papers to choose from

    2200 cons:
    -prints sloooower
    -costs $700
    -a lot of people had problems initially installing and running. Needs a lot of color managements at 1st.
    -their old styles known for their cloggin heads.

    So do you guys think the info I gathered is pretty much accurate? If not please correct me and give me more details on the printer you have.

    Anymore pros n cons to add?
    Thanks a lot.

  • #2
    You've done a lot of very good research.

    Can't help you with your decision, but here's a pretty comprehensive review on the Epson 2200 (known as the Epson Stylus Photo 2100 A3 printer in the UK) if you haven't seen it:

    click on the 'reviews' button in the left frame and 2100 review.



    • #3
      I can't answer your question either. I've just recently switched to the i9100 from an older Epson and I'm delighted with the results. Would I be happy with the Epson. Absolutely. But for me the savings, print look, speed and quietness sold me on the 9100. I think most of my clients can live with a 25 year print. If they need archival, I'll farm it out. Before you buy, print a pic off both printers and compare. Which do you prefer?



      Related Topics


      • id_viorel
        Thank U all...
        by id_viorel
        Thank U all...I did't thought that I will have an answer so quickly and I thank U all...From your answers I see that I have not been too explicit refering to what I need...I am new in photo world and don't know too many things about printers. I have learned today that I need an Ink Jet printer, because...
        05-27-2003, 12:05 PM
      • patpilipuf
        New Printer Purchase
        by patpilipuf
        I have two Epson printers: the 2000p and the C80. I do a lot of photo restoration and I also use my printers to create elements for collage work and altered books. Lately much of my work has been in black and white and sepia. The output from my 2000p has been very inconsistent and I am forced to use...
        01-19-2004, 12:06 PM
        Epson 1280 vs 2200
        by COLONELFLAG
        I am somewhat confused about buying a new printer. The printer would be used for making archival prints for my own use and also to make prints of retouched photos for clients.

        I have heard good things about the Epson 2200 with its 7 ink system and the different "blacks"...
        01-09-2003, 08:12 AM
      • Gerald McClaren
        Buying a reliable photo printer
        by Gerald McClaren
        I would like to get into photo restoration and is shopping for a photo printer. I had narrowed my selection to two photo printers. The printers are the Epson Stylus R800 and the Canon ip8500. I don't know which one to buy because both had great reviews and their ratings were very high. Can someone...
        09-02-2005, 11:40 PM
      • Gerry Monaghan
        Epson 5500 on a Mac G4 Yes No Opinions?
        by Gerry Monaghan
        Looking to get into pigmented ink printing. From what I am learning, the Epson 5500 is entry-level for this kind of equipment, and alot of people are not happy with performance. What is really being said by calling something a hundred year print, or a 25 year print?

        I am just starting...
        04-06-2002, 08:00 AM