Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Better to save in tiff or psd?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Better to save in tiff or psd?

    Friends:

    After I post process my image in Photoshop, is it better to save in Photoshop or Tiff format? What are the pros and cons?

    Thanks amigos?

    Migs

  • #2
    Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

    Tiff is the choice if you deliver the image to someone else, as it is readable by a wider range of applications.
    PSD will produce smaller filesize (even smaller if the option maximize compatibility is not checked - cause if you check, a flattened version is saved within the file)
    As you can (compress to) ZIP the Tiff later, using the OS, this is not really a problem.

    So I send (most of the times flattened) Tiffs to the client.
    Often I have to save the layered file as PSB, as the filesize of the layered file exceeds the 4GB limit.

    So, as often, it depends, what you want to do with the file.
    If you have Photoshop and want to archive, you can use psd.

    Comment


    • #3
      Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

      Hi girlsfather:

      Tiff saves as layered files? Like the Photoshop layers? If this is so, when opened in PS do the layers come back?

      Migs

      Comment


      • #4
        Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

        TIFF is a fully open file format (anyone can use it without paying a fee). PSD is the opposite. So far more software app’s can deal with a TIFF than a PSD for one. Next, expect for duotone support, anything you can save in a PSD you can save in a TIFF as well. Both are owned and controlled by Adobe but one is accessible to all. For that reason, I always save as TIFF (and often with Zip compression to save space albeit at a speed hit in opening and saving).

        Comment


        • #5
          Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

          Thanks Rodney!

          Comment


          • #6
            Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

            I save my images as layered PSD's on the off chance further modification will be required. I prefer to give my customers flattened tiffs to stop them fiddling with any of the elements in the retouched file!
            R.

            Comment


            • #7
              Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

              Good idea repairman! I have seen many people share files for printing using Acrobat too. -Migs

              Comment


              • #8
                Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

                TIFF is great because it's compatible to many programs, but it's also dangerous because of that.
                As TIFF is a Tagged Image File Format, if the tags one program writes are too complex for another program, it'll be a mess.
                A closer inspection of the TIFF format can be found here: http://www.openphotographyforums.com...ad.php?t=14243

                PSD on the other hand is only compatible to Photoshop, so it's not so easy to mess things up with other programs.

                Comment


                • #9
                  Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

                  Thanks for the insight Jonas!

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Re: Better to save in tiff or psd?

                    Jonas is right. TIFF is an attempt to be open and to address the thorny, serious problem of keeping our files usable for as long as possible, and it is overall accessible to more applications -- but TIFF has its own variations, too. Unless you save for the least common denominator of all of those, you're locking yourself out of some programs without even knowing which ones.

                    PSD is more closed as a format but it is monolithic and consistent. And rich in capabilities. And predictable (either an application supports PSD or it doesn't).

                    So unfortuately there is no free lunch. Both are good solutions depending on what you want to do. I use both for different situations. But I am using TIFF a lot more than I used to because some great non-Adobe programs like DxO Optics Pro and Capture One don't support PSD.
                    Last edited by RobertAsh; 07-06-2011, 12:18 PM.

                    Comment

                    Related Topics

                    Collapse

                    • Photo Grafix
                      Do you use Photoshop's Layered TIF format?
                      by Photo Grafix
                      For the first time in a few years, I have seriously considered reviewing a change in workflow for my working files. That is, I may start saving as TIF with layers as opposed to the native Adobe Photoshop PSD format. If you are doing this, please explain why? Is it smaller file sizes? Better compatibility?...
                      01-02-2006, 01:28 PM
                    • kenwood
                      Save to what format?
                      by kenwood
                      Hi I have been saving to psd format to preserve layer information but the resulting file is too big (50-100mb each). Is there an alternative?
                      08-15-2008, 10:25 AM
                    • ebbtide
                      changing default save format from psd to jpeg
                      by ebbtide
                      Hi,
                      Fixing up a bunch of Jpeg images and want to resave them in jpeg. Photoshop, of course, wants you to save them in psd by default. Is there a method so you don't have to go through all the key strokes to change from psd to jpeg for each image you save? Is there a method to permanently change...
                      08-13-2005, 08:51 AM
                    • shadowless33
                      JPEG to PSD is it possible?
                      by shadowless33
                      hey all i am new here. i am learning graphic designing and wanna know is it possible to convert any *.JPEG photo to *.PSD via any software?
                      Regards.
                      01-10-2012, 08:09 AM
                    • Caravaggio
                      converting files from psd to psb
                      by Caravaggio
                      A psd file I am working on has gotten too big to save as a psd. If I convert it to psb format will there be any degradation of the image? I did the conversion and there was none that I could tell, but I would like to hear from more knowledgable users than myself. I would save to the more common tif...
                      02-21-2011, 03:51 PM
                    Working...
                    X